Saturday, March 25, 2006

Weekly 3/25/06 - 5


Our Salon blog is a promising interactive site:   http:lloydhouse.blogspot.com  .  Without joining anything, you can respond to the current Weekly.   Also we have a Yahoo Group.  See the end of this email for details.  ellen


Salon Weekly



~ In 4  Color Coded Sections:

  • Table Notes
  • Announcements
  • Articles
  • Books, Reviews, Magazines





A Weekly Email Publication of The Lloyd House
Circulation:  525
Growing out of the Monday Night Salon
For info about the Salon, see the bottom of this email
Join us at the Lloyd House every Monday of the year at 5:45 for pot luck and discussion.
3901 Clifton Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio
to Submit events for the Weekly, send (not attachment) me email, subject line "Weekly-Events:(description)", in times New Roman Maroon color
to submit articles, send (not attachment) email, subject line: "Weekly-Articles-(description)", in Times New Roman, Navy color.
Saves me a lot of work that way.







To: Friends on our Pot Luck Salon list. 

(to unsubscribe see below, bottom of page).  



From Ellen: Have you ever noticed a period of off-kilter when the season turns?  Spring started Monday, and by Thursday it felt like a maelstrom of breakage on all fronts.  My appointment calendar disappeared, my computer system became utterly dysfunctional, the cat won't eat, I misplaced my daily journal, I came within a whisker of running out of gas on the highway, and a starling got into the house through one of the many chimneys.  And this is the weekend of Shanti... all day rehearsal.  Plus the morning meeting with the CowShare raw milk people to address the persecution of the governmental regulatory agents of our dairy farmer.  I mean!  I tell myself the challenge is to release the habits of tightening my neck, my heart, and remembering to turn it all over to the Higher Power, to choose love over fear, and focus on the beckoning light.
   We discussed Islam last Monday, even though Karen couldn't make it (see below).  Surely the Salon group, like Islam, is devoted to the inspiring idea of human community that is peaceful, just, loving, and intelligent to solve our common problems and care for one another and the world.  Yet the problem as I see it is that Islam seems to call for unanimity of position, while we believe in ever widening circles of respect and inclusion as the path to enlightenment.  That's why we like separation of church and state.  (Maybe I should not say "we"... I'll just speak for my own self.)  It's the  Dutch dilemma: central to that culture is the idea of tolerance and freedom, and so they welcome workers from the middle east, who come and bring with them a rigid doctrinaire conformism, threatening the very spirit that opened the door to them in the first place.  Well, and then there is the neo-marxian analysis that says inherent in the capitalist system is the need for fresh sources of low paying labor.  Ah...
   In a couple of weeks things will settle.  By Passover (Easter) the moon will be full again, and we will have come to know and name the infant Spring, unique this year, as every year.  The tiny flowers came early this year, yellow Winter Akonite, Snow Drops, Scilla.  And now of course, the riot of daffodils.  The challenge, as always: open the heart.  Ellen

................................................................................................................................



Did you know that Ellen Bierhorst Ph.D. is a holistic psychotherapist with over 30 years experience serving individuals and  families?  Expert, caring, rapid service.  Most insurance plans will cover.    Call 513 221 1289.  Special areas of interest: issues of  young adulthood, couple communication, GLBT, trauma recovery using EMDR, clinical hypnosis, parenting skills, addictions (tobacco, alcohol, drugs, overeating), weight loss.  What is "holistic"? Ans: body/mind/spirit; open to alternative healing modalities from chiropractic to homeopathy, acupuncture, etc.




Section One: Table Notes
................................................................................................................................



At the Table on Monday
Table 3/20/06
Present:
Spencer Konicov, Brigitte Thomas, Sharri Able, Rick Tallarigo, Cheryl Hayden, Janet Kalven, Nancy Dawley, Marvin Kraus, Gerry Kraus, Diane Fishbein, Zach Stauffer, Ilya Stein, Vlasta Molak, Thurman Henderson, Ellen Bierhorst.  
Mr. G.
s
Announcements:

Ellen on Shanti
Mira: on Tues, tomorrow at 2 at TUC, Ramsey Clark to talk.   
On Enquirer, Women in Black article, photo of Sr. Alice, Mira, ...   
Mike: SOS Mokbee peace and justic art show, Aplril 21 to May 7,  I 'll do a discussion onj LPeak Oil with discussion on "Islands of sustainability in the post carbon world."   
Vlasta:Tues 10 am Gai Foundation to present PreDevelopment Conf at 330 Central Pkw, City kDevel. Office.  "Gai Oasis", phase One of SEARCH (Sustained ...Fenewal of Cincinnati's Heart).  Green developmenht.   
Also at 1:30 there will be a presentation  on the LBanks at City Hall.   




Special Presentation:  on Islam and Muslims

Karen Dabdoub did not make it to the table. (She had Two family members fall ill and could not leave them.  She will reschedule.)

Marvin, hogreve.

Thurman:  My background is physics and engineering, not religion.  Am a researcher.  UC, my research field (I didn't get this.  I think it is tiny electronic gizmos, like that can be used in surgery with babies...ellen).  I like original sources.  I saw on the Weekly that Ellen and others had gone to the Mosque after the bombing late last year.  Koran is the original source.  ... I wanted to understand how the extremists came to be.   As I read the Koran I did find where the terrorist extremists got their motivation.  I read about heads rolling;... women having a vote of one half a man, in essence.  Was not able to find where the terrorists could rationalize suicide bombing, because the Koran says don't kill yourself.  For Orthodox Muslims the Koran is considered The word of God.  So it carries weight.   
  There are orthodox and reform versions of various religions.  I have looked at attitudes towards violence in various holy books.  The Koran is a good deal more violent in its orthodoxy than the others I have read.  In the original Arabic I have heard it is beautiful poetry.  Writing style is different from the bible which is based on the Torah.  Though it refers to the Bible.  Koran does not have "story".   It assumes you know the stories of the bible.  "Abu Musa" = Moses, mentioned a thousand or so times.
  I was struck and troubled a bit by the violent orientation in the Koran.  Also by the attitude towards women.  For example, Koran says all agreements should be in writing, witnessed by two men or one man and two women.  In inheritance, a male will inherit twice as much as a female.  It overtly states that a man is superior to a woman.   
  More than anything I was bothered by the many times slavery mentioned.   The assumption is that it will be common.  ... A man can marry his slave (can have multiple wives)... the penalty for a crime by a slave is half that of a free person....   

Rick: a question you hear a lot is that Islam is more warlike in essence than other religions.  Did  you find anything in the Koran that tells   about Mohammed waging war against non Muslims?

Thurman: yes.  On the other hand, the Koran says Don't attack unless you have been attacked.  So  you can pick your sources.  It does say to kill the infidels ... but it is said he was referring  specifically to people in Medina and Mecca during the wars they had.  ... No doubt that Mohammed did lead his army.

Spencer:  Where did  you get your copy of the Koran?
Thurman: maybe at the UC Bookstore.  I understand the English translation loses the beauty of the poetry. (P.S. from Ellen: you can request a beautiful edition of the Koran from CAIR.org.  I did, last summer.  They are back ordered and mine has not arrived yet.  It is easy to get a copy of the Koran.  I have a paperback version.  Karen Dabdoub recommends the translation in the edition at CAIR.  I am sure you can get any number of versions at the public library.)
Brigitte: I understand that in the beginning Islam was an inclusive religion, but became more and more exclusive.  In the beginning, Muslims prayed  to Jerusalem, but then changed to   M e cca.  What happens, when many religions  s t a rt out open and welcoming of other faiths but then become more and more narrow.

Thurman:  The Koran shows respect for "People of the Book", the Torah (Jews) and the Gospel (Christians).  ...  In one place in the Koran it seems to be saying that if you are a Jew or Christian you are all right; yet in other places the opposite seems to be said.   

Mira:
Last week on Diane Rheems show she had 2 experts on Islam who said the Interpretation of "Jihad" has changed over time.  To some it means holy war, but really it has more to do with convincing.   In every religion including humanists there is a version of the Golden Rule.  ... Strangers are not only welcomed, but it is a big deal to welcome and give food to strangers.   
  An anti homosexual point of view.  I have not heard what they say about that.   

Thurman:   
Jihad.  I don't recall reading that word but I have  been told it means strongly dedicated to whatever it may be.  Does not inherently mean violence.
Homosexuality:  it is mentioned two or three times.  Refers to Lot (Sodom and Gomorah) "Abomination".   

Mike:
I hear you when  you disapprove of the abundant violence in the Koran.  But I think we should look at some of the violence in Christianity and Judaism.   The promised land, just kill the inhabitants.  The pope, ... Crusades.   
We humans are evolving but perhaps our religions are not.  ...   

Thurman:
Excellent point.  As a researcher I am inclined to separate the basis from the interpretation.  In so-called Christianity, (New Test. mostly pacifist).  Spanish inquisition, crusades done in the name of Christianity.  I contend they were not following the Bible when they did that.   
But my judgement is that the level of violence is dramatically greater in the Koran than in the bible.   
...
Gerry:
Two questions.  Was the Koran written by a single source or was it a compilation?
What were the origins of Islam, was it a reform of something else, like Christianity was a reform of Judaism?

Thurman:
Origins: Mohammed was orphanbed, traveled with Uncle.  Influenced by Christians and Jews.   
The Kaaba (that black cubical structure in Mecca that is the object of pilgrimage.  ellen.) was revered before Mohammed.  A hundred statues to various tribal gods.
Mohammed declared only one God; do away with the idols.   
Allah is the God of Abraham.
The Muslims believe... sacrifice by Abraham of his son... at Moriah, dome of the rock.   Muslims believe that happened at Mecca.  Abraham built the Kaaba.  That the temple fell into paganism later on.  The place where Mohamed leapt into heaven on his horse was under the dome of the rock.   

Shari:  What is the publication date of the Koran.   

Thurman:
Other material says people take the Koran to be the words of the prophet, though Mohammed was illiterate.  Others wrote down his revelations.  They were compiled after his death.  There is another body of text that is Mohammed's teachings; but the Koran is believed to be revealed by God through the angel Gabriel  to Mohammed.  c. 620 a.d.

Shari:
In my reading of the old Testament you have an angry God, also admonishing people with threats if you don't believe....   

Thurman:   
...     horrible punnishments in the after life for sinners... boiling etc.

Ilya:  
Judaism has orthodoxy, reform, etc.  Is there that in Islam?

Thurman:  I haven't seen that.  
I would like to ask a Muslim myself.  Clearly there is a  spectrum regarding adherence to violence.  I trust that there is a reform version of Islam.   

Marvin:
Is there any reference to afterlife,  How get there?
Thurman:
very much.  Also believe in resurrection.  In the New Testament some emlphasize grace others on works.  The Koran very much into works.  Look after the orphans ... giving ... kind to travelers ...   

Ellen: Karen Armstrong's book on the history of Islam:  the community, the state is the holy thing.  Not doctrine as it is in Christianity.  As I understood it, the core of Islam is the idea, the ideal of having a holy societal organization.  This is, of course, the opposite from the separation of church and state.  But what a beautiful idea.

(p.s. f rom Ellen: a propos of separation of church and state:  My friend  Richard Blumberg who fairly foams at the mouth at the  nastiness of Allah, of Yaweh, et al, is fond of quoting some pundit who said We won't have justice, peace, until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest.  He is an ardent proponent of the separation of church and state.)

Thurman:  
Visiting the Middle East a couple of  years ago.  Arab guide, spoke about the importance of the community.  The King left law enforcement to the local tribes for the most part.  The local senior leaders.   

Mike: thank you Thurman for  your careful and judicious presentation.
Jesus was not a Christian; was a Reformed Jew. ... Jesus, boils down to Golden Rule.  Goes back to the Ageless Wisdom.   
  Islam; Mohammed said Jesus is not God.  Only one God.   
  But there are these evolutionary shine-throughs.  Kabbalah in Judiasm.  Albagensianism in S. France.   Sufis in Islam.  ... None of the major faiths are monolithic.  There is the Suni and the Shiia in Islam.  But a perennial seed in all of them.

  
Marvin:  Brigitte raised the question, are religions becoming more narrow.  Mike's point is just the opposite.  More and m ore splinters from every religion.   

Mr. G.  I think religions are like beasts in the Darwin sense.  One reason religion is stron g in the West (I think he means "in America".  ellen) is that there is no state religion.   
They compete with each other.  Sometimes the liberal version of the religion wins, sometimes the narrow version wins.

Spencer:  I am reminded of what Dan Hershey said here last week.  If you are open, your religion is o pen, accept ideas coming in and changing your interpretation, then your faith continues to grow.  But when the religion says "no, this i s it."  then it dies.   
I have a hard time drawing a line between politics and religion.  Zealots in both.   

Mike:  
a lot of times people try to take religion back to basics, but get caught in fundamentalism.  I have a sheet with ten versions of the golden rule from different religions.

Shari:
all religions            have in common that they contradict themselves.  If we can embrace contradictions or at least acknowledge them.

Rick:
I was looking at census data.  The ARIS survey asks religious affiliation.  Between 1990 and 2001 greatest growth in Islam (200%) and Buddhism as well.  But no growth in Christianbity and Judaism except for evangelical groups.   
Marvin
Judaism is about to embark on this huge marketing campaign (laughter)

Thurman:
re. narrowness and inclusiveness.  I just saw some statistics about growth in Christian churches.  The mainline churches, which have become more inclusive over time, are losing members, and evangelical groups growing.  750% growth over 15 years of "Assemblies of God".  That group was only 500,000 to begin with.  but in foreign countries they have millions!  They are not doctrinaire, but are evangelical; attitude of inclusive re. ethnicities and peoples.   The Crossroads and The Vineyard.   Churches that are growing rapidly.

Brigitte: I meant that in the beginning of Islam there was respect for Jews and Christians; now animosity has grown and grown.  Interpretations seem to have  become m ore rigid.

Gerry:   
Marvin and I last week saw a video from 1994, "Jihad in America".  Stephen Emerson's research.  An Iraqi native collaborator.  A woman.  Attended U.S. mosque meetings wearing traditional garb.  According to this video jihad is alive and well here in US.  In almost every mosque there are probably jihadists.  The concern was ... whatever it was in the 600's, right now Islam looked nasty in this video.   

Spencer:  we've been talking about little elements of religion, and I was talking about the macro ... the society as a whole needs to be open to all so as to be healthy.  Once we start enclosing ourselves off, close our borders, then we get into trouble.   

Anonymous: I know somebody who work at IRS.  A story.  There is a TV screen in the lobby running little videos... says CFIRE, Christian Fundamentalist study group.  What is that doing in the IRS lobby?   My friend wrote to the ACLU.  After a while the TV announcement disappeared.   

Spencer:  the 22 and 29 of March at Golf Manor Synagogue on Stover, there will be a class on the passover Haggadah.   

Ellen: (we need to hear from conservatives.  OUr table should be more inclusive.   )


(We are grateful to Thurman for sharing what he had learned about Islam and hope that he will come back and talk with us about sustainable energy.)

~ end of table notes ~

Hugs to everyone,
Ellen






Section Two: Announcements







Hey Lloyd House Drumming Circle!
Every Saturday evening, 7 - 9 only, drumming, musical improv, dance, chant, jam.  Wonderful fun.  
Note: on Saturday March 25, however, we are not having the drumming circle because of two amazing competing events that many of us wanted to attend:  Shanti, a Journey of Peace at the Aronof, and the Crystlas Expo with drummer Toby Christensen at Raymond Walters College.  
  So, hope to see you there, and in future Saturdays , here for the Lloyd House Drumming Circle.  ellen


For your convenience, here are directions to the Midwest Crystal Conference & Expo This weekend:

Location: Raymond Walters College / Muntz Hall
     9555 Plainfield Rd
     Cincinnati, OH 45236

I-275
to Reed Hartman Hwy exit. Take Reed Hartman South to Plainfield Road. Right on Plainfied. Raymond Walters is .1 mile on  Left.

I-71 to Ronald Reagan Hwy West to Plainfield/Hunt Rd exit. Left on Hunt. Right at 1st light onto Plainfield. At 2nd light turn Left. Raymond Walters is .1 mile on Left.

I-75 to Ronald Reagan Hwy East to Plainfield Rd exit. Left on Plainfield. At 3rd light turn Left. Raymond Walters is .1 mile on Left.

......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Muntz Hall is 1st building on Left. Follow signs to parking.




Women¹s History Month 2006   women's FILM FESTIVAL

Women¹s History Month 2006

Thursday March 30, 2006                                                                                                     5:00pm ­ 7:00pm                                                                                                                                Iron Jawed Angels Film Viewing and Discussion                                                                                 571 Steger Student Life

Katja von Garnier's "Iron Jawed Angels" tells the remarkable and little-known story of a group of passionate and dynamic young women, who put their lives on the line to fight for American women's right to vote. This true story has startling parallels to today, as the young activists struggle with issues such as the challenges of protesting a popular President during wartime and the perennial balancing act between love and career.


Profiles of Outstanding Women Faculty, Staff, and Students displayed in TUC Atrium and the Women¹s Center throughout the month of March

patricia.carroll@uc.edu



Next Major Peace Demonstration in D.C.


April 29





PEACE, JUSTICE, FREEDOM, THE EARTH: JOINING THEM ON APRIL 29




For the first time, an important part of the environmental movement and an important part of the antiwar movement, as well as the National Organization for Women and others, are joining to bring an end to  "global scorching" and the Iraq War as well as to end attacks on the Constitution and on the poor and the middle class by the present US government.

This broad coalition is calling for a major march in New York City on April 29.

Says the call to this march:

·      No more never-ending oil wars!   
·      Protect our civil liberties & immigrant rights, and end illegal  spying, government corruption and the subversion of our democracy.   
·      Rebuild our communities, starting with the Gulf Coast. Stop corporate  subsidies and tax cuts for the wealthy while ignoring our basic needs.
·      Act quickly to address the climate crisis and the accelerating destruction  of our environment.

Among the initiating groups are ---
United for Peace and Justice
NOW
Rainbow/PUSH Coalition
US Labor Against the War
Friends of the Earth
Climate Crisis Coalition
Peoples Hurricane Relief Fund

Readers of The Shalom Report will be especially interested to know that UPJ has decided to refuse any further alliances with "ANSWER" in organizing any demonstrations, etc.

The UPJ steering committee did this by a two-thirds majority,  out of its experience both of deep political differences between ANSWER & UPJ  in organizing  the antiwar actions last September, and of serious failures by ANSWER to adhere to and carry out commitments the two groups had agreed to beforehand.

You may recall that The Shalom Center was so indignant about the involvement of the bitterly anti-Israel ANSWER in the September 24 antiwar rally that we held an independent  pro-peace Shabbat service during the rally time of that weekend,and then took part in other aspects of the weekend when ANSWER had no role.

Now we can take whole-hearted part, especially since our other concerns ­ Oil, Global Scorching, the US Constitution ­ are also on the agenda.

###################

The Climate Crisis Coalition has just installed a Climate Crisis News Engine on its website (www.climatecrisiscoalition.org).  Each morning from its various ³newsfeeds,² CCC identifies a dozen or so stories to post on the site.  They get rotated on the home page.  (To see all the stories click Climate Crisis News Engine

http://www.climatecrisiscoalition.org/climatenews/


###########
Shalom, Arthur

Rabbi Arthur Waskow, director
The Shalom Center www.shalomctr.org voices a new prophetic agenda in Jewish, multireligious, and American life. To receive the weekly on-line Shalom Report, click on --
http://www.shalomctr.org/subscribe


Local Forest Habitat Restoration Events
Local Forest Habitat Restoration Events and Neighborhood Clean Up - Clifton (corrected, thanks to Steve Slack)

Green Up Day and Great American Cleanup dates have been realigned.

April 22 is the Great American Clean Up coordinated by Keep Cincinnati Beautiful.
Kerry Crossen P 513.352.4384  F 513.352.4389    www.keepcincinnatibeautiful.org

May 6th is Green Up Day coordinated by the Cincinnati Park Board. Burnet Woods garlic mustard.
Cindi Nugent 861-8970 x20

Rawson Woods April 29, 10-12.  garlic mustard pull and trash clean up. Meet your neighbors at the corner of Middleton and McAlpin. Info. Joy at 221-8285.






4/2


Children of Abraham Peace Walk
Sunday April 2

From Unity Church on McMillain near Woodburn Ave
to Hillell Student Center on Clifton Ave (Jewish)
to Islamic Center on clifton Ave.


For details and sponsorship info. check out www.NTUnity.org  and click on the Abraham link.
Steve Sunderland said at the table that the xenophobia against Muslims is worse now than it was right after 9/11!  We must stand against this.  The Peace Walk is about a 4 mile hike by my reckoning, but you can join it at any point.  Starts at  1:00.  Hope to see you there.  I want to wear the purple interfaith unity t shirt that Robin brought over.  Ellen

P.S.  Karen Dabdoub, our presenter on  Monday 3/20 is involved also in this walk.  





SAVE THE DATE:  Saturday, April 8, 2006
 
News From:  The Cincinnati Police Department and The Community Police
Partnering Center
 
Please forward to all of your contacts.
 
Save the date of Saturday, April 8th from 9:00 AM to 3:00 PM for the
very first CPOP (Community Problem Oriented Policing) Summit
.  The CPOP
Summit will provide useful information and best practices to CPOP team
members, faith based groups, block watch clubs, Community Council
members, and anyone who is working to improve their neighborhood.  The
Summit will be held at the brand-new Community Action Agency, located
at the corner of Reading and Langdon Farm in Jordan¹s Crossing. 

Additional details will follow.
 
For more information or to RSVP, please call or email Tracey Wilson at
the Partnering  Center, 559 ­ 5450 or
twilson@gcul.org.




4/8





SPAN Ohio to sponsor all day conference on
Single Payer Health Care for Ohioans


Sat. April 8   10 am  to 4 pm
Holiday Inn City Center  175 E. Town St.  (614-221-3281)
Columbus, OH

This is the group that Dr. Don Rucknagel supports, the doc. who gave us that great power point presentation a couple of weeks ago.  Let's throw our energy behind this initiative.  I am looking to form a car pool-drive up and back same day.  Call me, ellen: 221 1289.

To register ($15 fee, includes lunch) see
www.spanohio.org or email spanhealthcare@aol.com

SPAN Ohio tidbit: Myth: "Universal Health Car will cost too much." Reality: not more, less!  25 to 30 cents of every dollar spent on health care currently goes to  the insurance companies and HMOs.  Compare this with only 2.9 cents for every health dollar that goes to Medicare.  Look at that difference!   If those billions were used for patient care instead of to the insurance and HMO companies, that would provide much of the funding required to cover the medical needs of all Ohioans.   Learn more at
www.spanohio.org


April 22
MUSE Silent Auction - Latin Music by Jackie Rago

(note from Ellen: Jackie Rago is a fireball Latina, the most amazing bongo player, assorted percussion instrumentalist I have ever heard anywhere.  Very cute to watch as well.  I will be shelling out for this event.  And you can get fabulous bargains at the silent auction.  Plus... Muse deserves our support!)

Order Tickets Now! <
https://www.musechoir.org/shop/index.php?cPath=23>

www.musechoir.org <
http://musechoir.org/>

MUSE ­ Cincinnati¹s Women¹s Choir
presents


4th Annual Gala Evening with the Muses
featuring Latin music
by Jackie Rago



Catherine Roma ­ Artistic Director

Saturday, April 22




St. John¹s Unitarian Universalist Church
320 Resor Ave (Clifton)

Silent Auction

Wine & Cheese
Private Performance by Jackie Rago
6:30PM

Public Concert with Jackie Rago
8PM

Entire Event: $40
Public Concert Only: $15

Tickets available online at:
www.musechoir.org <
http://www.musechoir.org>  
muse@musechoir.org
(513) 221-1118

handicap accessible, sign language
childcare available with reservation by April 14
Call (513) 221-1118

MUSE receives operating support from:
City of Cincinnati
Ohio Arts Council
Community Shares
Fine Arts Fund






Lloyd House has Space Available



2/18/06  So  Matthew  has a new romance, so suddenly I have his beautiful space available as well as the small single on third floor.  I'd like either to find two  new housemates or else form a group who wants to co-own the property and live in a co-housing style here helping me to handle the maintenance and utilities.  

Matthew's 2 rooms on third floor. NE corner of house.  One E facing window, 2 small N facing windows.  Private full bath. Furnished with beautiful teak queen size bed and dresser, desk, wood and glass dining table for 4, coffee table, chaise longue, two beautiful dhurrie rugs.  Room adjoins spacious and beautiful zendo turret room used for meditation, yoga, drum circle, etc. Shares third floor kitchen with 3 other housemates. $420.
Jason's room, small single on third floor, one W facing window, double bed size suspended sleeping loft, large closet.  Bathroom right outside the door in the hall. Shares third floor kitchen with 3 other housemates. $350.
Also, first floor room for office, studio, ...?  This is a large oak paneled room with Rookwood fireplace.  Currently furnished with king size loft bed platform, sofa, arm chair, Dhurrie rug, long oak library table.  Could share the living room with me as a waiting room.  Has its own outside entry door.  A very handsome room.  Terrific for massage practice, for instance.  $320?
And come summer barring a miracle job for Alan in the city, we will have his beautiful two room suite available on second floor, plus sleeping porch.  
Other Perqs: off street parking, free laundry, high speed internet, living room with piano, TV, DVD, VCR, community iMac Computer.  Dining room seats 16+.  Veranda off dining room with Hatteras swing, furniture.  Easy access to Monday night salon pot luck, Saturday morning Dharma Study group, Sat. evening drumming circle, and ....
The Lloyd House is a stimulating, friendly, multi-cultural environment.  Good vibes are required, as is a rock solid financial responsibility.  Housemates can be as private or as friendly as they wish.  Know anyone who might like to explore this?  No undergraduates, no pets, no smoking.  Prefer someone who would be interested in participating in the Salon and/or other activities here.  Call me: 221 1289  


P.S.  It feels like something new might be about to happen with regard to the use of the Lloyd House.  Help me dream that up.  221 1289  or email   Ellen   ellenbierhorst@lloydhouse.com v


 
Tri-State Treasures
Tri-State Treasures is a compilation of unique local people, places, and events that may enrich your lives.  These treasures have been submitted by you and others who value supporting quality community offerings.  Please consider supporting these treasures, and distributing the information for others to enjoy.  And please continue to forward your Tri-State Treasures ideas to jkesner@nuvox.net.
I need your help: please submit your Tri-State Treasure
in the format exemplified at the bottom of this email.  Thank you.

Sincerely,  Jim
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 
2006 Cincinnati Israeli Film Festival [through March 30]:  Outstanding films you'll never see anytime anywhere else by & about Jewish people & their culture.  More info on films, locations, & more @ www.jewishcincinnati.org/content_display.html?ArticleID=176434.
 
Call for Entries for the next Quarterly Underneath Cincinnati:  Accepting submissions for the April 16th screening to be held at the Southgate House in Newport, KY.  All original, independently produced films under 30 minutes are eligible.  See your film screened in the Southgate House Ballroom on a 25 foot high screen with a professional sound system.  Become eligible for the 2006 Best of Underneath to be held at the world renown Contemporary Arts Center.  Showing your film & getting feedback is better then letting it sit on the shelf.  And it's free.  Send your film to Underneath Cincinnati, PO Box 19928, Cincinnati, OH 45219.  More info @ sara@underneathcincinnati.com & www.underneathcincinnati.com.
 
Globalization: Its History, Meaning, & Complexities [Thursday 23 March @ 1:40-2:55 PM]:  Lecture by Gareth Howell, President & CEO of the Global Center of Greater Cincinnati.  Mr. Howell¹s distinguished career in international affairs includes positions in the International Labor Organization of the United Nations & the World Bank. He has advised the governments of Bosnia-Herzegovina, China, India, Colombia, Kenya, Mexico, Mozambique, & Pakistan.  Presented by Northern Kentucky University International Studies Club & Political Science Honor Society Xi Omega. Free & open to the public.  Free & open to all.  At 110 Landrum Academic Center, Northern Kentucky University, Highland Heights, KY 41099 (Stop at parking attendant booth for free pass & directions to Landrum.) More info @ 513-621-2320 pollitja@nku.edu, wacgc@globalcincinnati.org.
 
Cincinnati Iraq Veteran Against the War Speaks Out [Saturday 25 March @ 11 AM]:  Harvey Tharp, local member of Iraq Veterans Against the War will speak about his experience in Iraq, the military, recruiters, other issues. He will be attending the March 14-19 march from Mobile Alabama to New Orleans which is being initiated by Veterans for Peace & other groups to highlight the connections between the economic & human cost of war in the Middle East & the failure of our government to respond to human needs at home, especially the needs of poor people & people of color.  At Peaslee Neighborhood Center, 215 East 14th Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202. More info @ 513.579.8547, kristen@ijpc-cincinnati.org, www.ivaw.net, & www.vetgulfmarch.org.
 

Reunion of 14 Artists [Saturdays & Sundays thru April 30 @ 1-5 PM, Friday 7 April @ 6-10 PM, & by appt ]:
Fourteen women artists who shared the CO-OP Gallery for 18 years on East 4th Street, Downtown Cincinnati, are reuniting with 100 pieces of art of their respective art forms.  The art & artists have only improved with time.  Artists are Alice Balterman, Ruth Banta, Arnelle Dow, Renee Harris, Robert Glover, Jan Marx Knoop, Vivian Kline, Mary Mark, Sally Murray, Susan Naylor, Elizabeth O'Neill, Nikki Orlemann, Anne Straus, & Maggie Wenstrup.  At Gallery 646, 646 Main Street, Mainstrasse Village, Covington, KY 41011.  More info at 859.630.2432.
 
Moonlight & Magnolias [Thru March 26]:  What do you mean you never read "Gone With the Wind"?!? Set in Hollywood in 1939 & inspired by real events, this is the hilarious behind-the-scenes look at the frenetic collaboration to get the screenplay of GWTW written - in only 5 days. By Ron Hutchinson.  $5 Off Adult Tickets When you Mention This Email - Offer Valid March 9-17 for any evening performance.  At Ensemble Theatre of Cincinnati,  1127 Vine Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202 More info @ 513.421.3555, Jocelyn.Meyer@cincyetc.com, & www.mailermailer.com/x?u=47419727x-09eae5da.

 
A Sip of Irish Culture [thru Friday 31 March]:  Original works by local artist Cynthia R. Matyi are on exhibit & for sale.  Ms. Matyi is a visionary artist ­ a creative thinker whose works depict feelings of spirituality, fantasy, humor, & reverence for our natural world. She incorporates interlacing, spiraling, restless style patterned after a rhythmic Celtic approach. At Awakenings Coffee & Tea, 2734 Erie Avenue, Hyde Park, Cincinnati, OH 45208.  More info @ 513.3212525 & mary.ward@cinci.rr.com.
 
Othello Molineaux @ Jazz At The Hyatt [Friday  24 March @ 8 PM - midnight]:  Othello Molineaux is the originator of Jazz Steel Drumming (www.othellomolineaux.com). He will be playing with RM:Intrin-x-ico, the Rolando Matias Quartet with Eddie Bayard.  No-holds barred straight-ahead jazz.  $15 cover; $5 for members. At the Sungarten Room, Hyatt Hotel Cincinnati, 151 West 5th Street, Downtown Cincinnati, OH 45202. More info @ 513.579.1234, waltb31@fuse.net, & www.jazzincincy.com.
 
Fiddler On The Roof [March 23 - April 9]:  The classic based on the book by Joseph Stein, lyrics by Sheldon Harnick, & music by Jerry Bock. In the little village of Anatevka, Tevye, a poor dairyman, tries to instill in his five daughters the traditions of his tight-knit Jewish community in the face of changing social mores & the growing anti-Semitism of Czarist Russia.  Rich in historical & ethnic detail, ³Fiddler On The Roof² has touched audiences around the world with its humor, warmth, & honesty.  It's universal theme of tradition cuts across barriers of race, class, nationality, & religion, leaving audiences crying tears of laughter, joy, & sadness.  Score includes "Sunrise, Sunset," "If I Were A Rich Man," & "Matchmaker," to name a few.  $20 for adults; $18 for seniors & students. At Covedale Center for the Performing Arts, 4990 Glenway Avenue, Western Hills, Cincinnati, OH 45238.  More info, schedule & times @ 513.241.6550, jenniferperrino@covedalecenter.com, & www.cincinnatilandmarkproductions.com.
 
Missing Your Neighborhood Officer? [Saturday 25 March @ 9AM-12PM]: Woman¹s City Club invites you to join a Neighborhood Building Conversation to build & deepen relationships with each other & those who serve us. A focal point of the conversation will be the loss of the Cincinnati Police Departments neighborhood officers. Rekindle hope & change frustration into positive energy, deficiencies into strengths, & wants into possibilities. Free & open to those interested in being part of a creative, positive conversation. At the Cintas Center Ballroom, Xavier University, 1624 Herald Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45207. More info @ 513.751.0100 & wcc@womanscityclub.org.
 
From Broadway to Galway [Saturday 25 March @ 7 PM]:  The Friendly Sons of St. Patrick Foundation in Cincinnati will present an evening of Irish entertainment, a tribute to the great Irish tenor Frank Patterson.  The show will feature Broadway performing artists Ciaran Sheehan & Gay Willis, accompanied by concert pianist Eily O¹Grady Patterson.  From Galway to Broadway is currently on a US tour, which started at New York¹s Carnegie Hall this winter & will end at Radio City Music Hall. Tickets are $25, $35, & $45.  At Memorial Hall, 1229 Elm Street, Cincinnati, OH 45210.  More info @ 513.621.2787, matyi@fuse.net, & www.cincinnatiarts.org.
 
All-Night Star Party Races You Around the Universe [Saturdays 25 March & 1 April @ Dusk Å’Til Dawn]:  Astronomer Charles Messier cataloged deep space objects in the 1700s.  Now you can see all 110 of them in 1 night at a Messier Marathon.  Dozens of enthusiastic & knowledgeable astronomers will share some of the largest telescopes in the tri-state & guide you through the heavens.  Bring warm clothes, binoculars, telescopes, or whatever you have.  Set up begins at dusk but come at any time & stay as long as you like. Each program is weather dependent & only runs if there are clear skies.  Saturn & Jupiter will also be viewed.  Free & open to the public.  At Stonelick State Park Beach Area, 2895 Lake Drive, Pleasant Plain, OH 45162.  More info @ 513.575.5556, 513.321.5186, deanobservatory@zoomtown.com, & www.cincinnatiobservatory.org/stonelick.html.
 
Usui Reiki Levels I & II Training [Saturday-Sunday 25-26 March @ 9 AM- 5 PM]: Introduction & initiation to the 1st & 2nd level of this hands-on healing system. Each class includes lecture, demonstration & practice. No experience required for Level I. You'll learn to give treatments to self & others & to be able to do powerful distance healing & goal manifestation. Classes are approved for 8 hours each day for nurses. Attend one or both days. Registration: Level I is $125 on Saturday 25 March; Level II is $175 on Sunday 26 March.  Pre-registration with $50 deposit for each level is required by 18 March.  At WholeCare, 4434 Carver Woods Drive, Blue Ash, OH, 45242.  More info & registration: JoAnn Utley @ 502.777.3865 & jutley5122@bellsouth.net & http://joannutley.byregion.net.
 
Walnut Hills Branch Library Celebrates its Centennial [Saturdays 1 & 8 April]:  The Centennial birthday celebration will kick off with a Urban Used Book Sale sponsored by the Friends of the Public Library on Saturday 1 April @ 10 AM - 5 PM & Centennial Celebration on Saturday 8 April @ noon - 4 PM.  The Walnut Hills Branch Library opened on April 7, 1906, replacing 2 neighborhood deposit stations that operated from 1899-1906. Designed in the French Renaissance style, it was the first of 9 branch libraries in Cincinnati built through the generosity of philanthropist Andrew Carnegie. The twin columns at the entrance arrived from Munich with the Tyler Davidson Fountain, & later were incorporated into the building¹s design. Paintings in the adult reading room are the gift of a local artist. Other special features include the original birch-stained mahogany woodwork & the stained glass window in the vestibule.  At 2533 Kemper Lane, Cincinnati, OH 45206. More info @ 513.369.6959, rick.helmes@cincinnatilibrary.org, & www.CincinnatiLibrary.org.
 
³Lifting the Mask of Racism² Workshop [Monday 3 April @ 7 PM]:  Presented by the Rev. Paula Jackson & Sandra Driggins-Smith, of Church of Our Savior in Mt. Auburn, at the next meeting of the Neighbor to Neighbor organization, for residents of Pleasant Ridge, Kennedy Heights, Silverton, & other nearby neighborhoods.  This 2nd part of the 3-part workshop (final part is May 1) is designed to afford a safe environment for participants to face the evils of racism & express their feelings.  A review of part one begins the session.  At the Pleasant Ridge Presbyterian Church, 5950 Montgomery Road, Cincinnati, OH 45213. More info @ GRSnouffer@cinci.rr.com.
 
Booze 'N' Board Games [Monday 3 April @ 5:30-7:30 PM, but stay late & play games ]:  Invite everyone over to play board games without the drudgery of cleaning your house. Unwind & socialize after work while playing games from our youth.  Meet friends after work for Jenga or develop a toast element with Scrabble. Connect with Connect Four.  Have a drink before you surgically remove a funny bone in Operation.  Beat your date at Yahtzee.  Get to know someone over Trivial Pursuit.  Proceeds benefit The Know Theatre Tribe.  At Bar Louie, Newport on the Levee, 1 Levee Way, Newport, KY 41071.  More info @ 513.300.KNOW, 859-291-4222, info@knowtheatre.com, & http://www.knowtheatre.com/Shows/Events.shtml.
 
Yoga Nidra Relaxation & Meditation [Every Sunday @ 6-7:15 PM]: Free & open to all. $3 donation welcomed.  At the Kula Center, 110 E 8th Street, Newport, KY 41071.  More info from Rob @ 859.441.4144 & robburns1008@yahoo.com.
 


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Tri-State Treasures is compiled by James Kesner.
To submit Tri-State Treasures, or to request your email address to be added or removed
 from the list, send an email to
jkesner@nuvox.net and specify Tri-State Treasures.
 
Please submit Tri-State Treasures in the following format.  Also look at TSTs above for examples:
<10-word description of the treasure [date @ time]: Brief description of the treasure; what is it; why is it wonderful & unique. Cost. Sponsor. Location including address & zip code. More info @ telephone, email, & website
.



Section Three: Articles


Contents:

  • Harry Fry MD on single payer health care

From: harry fry <hffry@yahoo.com>
Date: Tue, 21 Mar 2006 07:00:26 -0800 (PST)
To: Ellen Bierhorst <ellenbierhorst@lloydhouse.com>
Subject: Networking and forum for health care reform


Ellen,



I have read with interest, and with admiration for what you are doing, the newsletters of your organization.  It appears that health care reform is important to you and your group.  It is to me and mine, NPC, the Nurse-Physician Collaborative.  At some point, those who provide and those who receive (the comsumers of) health care should get together to discuss the needs of reform.  I would like to be able to contact anyone you know who might be interested in creating a forum for that purpose.  Is it possible for you to provide me with the names of such persons, groups, and organizations?



Thank you for whatever you can do.

Harry Fry MD

Anyone?  ellen




3/17/06
SPAN Ohio is a citizen group working to promote a piece of well-crafted legislation that would result in a Medicare-like system of health care that would cover everyone in the state, saving huge amounts of our health dollars that would no longer go towards coping with the ungainly and unworkable private red tape tangle we now have, much less the equally huge amount of our health dollars that go to enriching the executives and share holders of the health insurance industry.  

   For us, the consumers, the only difference we would notice is that we would no longer have to worry if the particular doctor or other provider we want to see is "covered" by the particular insurance plan we happen to be enrolled in.  Every provider would be covered, and every patient in Ohio.  Furthermore, we would not have to worry about annual deductables.  The 1500 health care insurance companies, each m aking profits and each with its own bureaucracy and rules would no longer be involved in our health care.  Can't you just see how much better this would be?  
 Span Ohio is asking that we sign the petition requesting that the Ohio legislature enact the bill.  They will then have several months to do so.  If they do not, we will get more signatures on a petition to have the bill put on direct voter referendum to be voted up or down in November (2007 I believe).  
 You can sign a petition here at the Lloyd House, or go to..
www.spanohio.org
.Ellen Bierhorst




Section Four: Books, Reviews, Magazines




The Lloyd House Salon (usually about 15 people) Meets Mondays at 5:45,
EVERY MONDAY, 52 WEEKS/YEAR come hell or high water, as my mother used to say.

We of the Lloyd House Salon gather in a spirit of
respect, sympathy and compassion for one another
in order to exchange ideas for our mutual pleasure and enlightenment.  

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Our Salon blog is a promising interactive site:   http:lloydhouse.blogspot.com
   Interactive Yahoo Salon group, http://groups.yahoo.com/group/LloydHouseSalon
We have 45 members as of 7/05.  
For
Pot Luck  procedures including  food suggestions, mission and history visit
http://home.fuse.net/ellenbierhorst/Potluck.html   . 

You are invited also to visit the Lloyd House website:  http://www.lloydhouse.com




> To unsubscribe from the Lloyd House Potluck Salon list, send a REPLY message
> to me and in the SUBJECT line type in "unsub potluck #".  In the place of #
> type in the numeral that follows the subject line of my Weekly email.  It
> will be 1,2, 3, 4, 5, or 6.  This tells me which sub-list your name is on so I can  
> delete it.  Thanks!   ellen bierhorst     

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

early WEEKLY 3/7/06 - 5

Our Salon blog is a promising interactive site:   http:lloydhouse.blogspot.com  .  Without joining anything, you can respond to the current Weekly.   Also we have a Yahoo Group.  See the end of this email for details.  ellen





Salon Weekly




~ In 4  Color Coded Sections:

  • Table Notes
  • Announcements
  • Articles
  • Books, Reviews, Magazines










A Weekly Email Publication of The Lloyd House
Circulation:  525
Growing out of the Monday Night Salon
For info about the Salon, see the bottom of this email
Join us at the Lloyd House every Monday of the year at 5:45 for pot luck and discussion.
3901 Clifton Avenue
Cincinnati, Ohio
to Submit events for the Weekly, send (not attachment) me email, subject line "Weekly-Events:(description)", in times New Roman Maroon color
to submit articles, send (not attachment) email, subject line: "Weekly-Articles-(description)", in Times New Roman, Navy color.
Saves me a lot of work that way.










To: Friends on our Pot Luck Salon list.

(to unsubscribe see below, bottom of page).  



An abbreviated Weekly this week.  I am traveling to Denver to see daughter Anna.  Salon Monday as usual.  Please note: the community meeting in Corryville, "Think Tank" at the Corryville Rec. center, corner University and Eden, is tonight, not last night, at 6. See Announcements in maroon section below.  







Section One: Table Notes


At the Table on Monday, 3/6/06_: David Rosenberg, Mr. G., Cheryl Hadden, Shari Able, Janet Kalven, Chad Benjamin Potter, Kerry Conte , Neil Anderson, Mira Rodwan, Mike Murphy , Judy Cirillo, Vlasta Mollak, Rick Tallarigo, Spencer Konicov, Ellen Bierhorst, Steve Sunderland

Announcements:

Ellen: on Gary Oaks, harassed by the state Agriculture Dept. people today.  Had a heart attack.  See  article about this   breaking news in Articles section below in blue.

Mira: clarification re. Clifton development threat.
Vlasta: tomorrow at Hillel Center Hamentashen vs. Latke debate in honor of Purim.  
Chad:  I am going to St. Bernard Parish, just N of New Orleans end of March to clean up after Katrina, helping repair homes.  In Nov. my sister went down to help out and  had a great experience.  Going with the U.C. Honors program group.  with Nat¹l Relief Network www.NRN.org.  I need $399 for my food and transportation, tax deductible donation to Nat¹l Relief Network.  (we raised $181 sending around the basket.)

Mike: should we rebuild N.O.?

Topics Nominated:

Mike: should we rebuild N.O.
Shari: the United Arab Emirates and the ports
David Rosenberg:  I have an ODA story on milk, and a FDA story on vegetables.
Mira: update on Gray Rd.

Ellen: who do you distrust more?
Judy: on my mind lately: my son in law is a counselor in a grade schl.  UPset with numbers of fatherless kids; more in trouble, lower grades.  
Mike: Peak Oil, or ³petro collapse²
Mira: beautiful conversation with my daughter.  She and husband are inviting a child in their home; h is parents without contact for years.  Is in same middle school as my grandson.  African American.  Lives in an agency.  My dau. and husb are going to be sponsors for him.  ...  




Discussion:

( PLEASE NOTE: These notes have not been edited by the speakers and should not be taken as an accurate expression of the speakers¹ meanings.  ellen)

ODA Milk Story  See Dan Berwinkle's email reprinted below.

David they went to a farmer who was distributing raw milk, a sting operation.  He refused to sell.  ... he lost his livelihood..  Took away his license.  Terrorized this farmer.  
I am a little scared that this is about to h appen to vegetables.  Phobia about bacteria in foods.  It all started with sprouts.  Remember when sprouts got pulled off shelves because of ecoli.  Tonight I brought pea shoots... the FDA has expanded their ideas from sprouts to the micro greens like my peas.  They are changing produce from an agriculture dept to FDA issue ...  Industry wants to take product out of the hands of the independent producers.  The weak get preyed upon in their ability to conduct commerce.  If you are not part of the corporate empire , having a wage slavery.  ... you are out of luck.

Neil: cherry growers are getting pressure from FDA; the growers are claiming cherries are full of anti inflammatory properties.  on their web site.  in Life Extension mag. a long article.


David: the FDA is also not happy with the vitamin, supplements industry.  Can¹t control them because they are classed as food not drugs.  The FDA wants that classed rugs so the control.  Huge threat to our freedom.  

Neil: :Seems the FDA is protecting the pharmaceutical business.

Judy: public health nurse.  Bone tuberculosis in a child traced back to raw milk.  

David: There is some  good science shows that the industrial approach to food shows it is more dangerous than good clean small local independent producers.  
The FDA makes the producers do expensive tests on the seed used for sprouts.  

Mira: how is this handled in Germany? Canada?

David: Europe is doing a great job trying to keep the family farms in business.  

Ellen: which do you fear more, business or government?  are the regulations oppressive and bring down the creativity of free enterprise.  Or do we need them to balance the excesses of the We have no representation   sector.  How do you frame his argument?  Don¹t need this government protection?  Of  is the government just getting in the way of our pursuit of freedom and happiness?  We need freedom for our creativity to solve our problems.  Behind your back, those 2  arguments come together.   The FDA is not policing industry, it is harassing independent thinkers and producers  Industry has purchased government.  This brings together as allies true progressives and  conservatives.  How can we reach across this widening gulf between the 2 groups.  Think twice before you dismiss conservatives - we are fighting for the same thing.

Rick:  leads also into the Dubai issue.  The old division between corp. interest and government used to be clear, but now  isn't..  CEOs meeting government officials to determine policy.  Some very smelly operations.  Lobbyists writing legislation.  
   They maintain Fema, for instance, but emasculate them so they cannot be effective.  
   Take the mining safety regulatory OSHA .  They aren¹t doing their job.  Poor safety , no enforcement.  Not protecting the public trust.  Hey, if you believe with the Libertarians, get rid of the regulatory agencies, but don¹t pretend  them but strip them of funding...

Steve:  I think what Ellen said is not new.  We had business people in on the beginning of our country, and making sure that slavery was kept.  This was the deal .  We have been bought and sold right from the beginning.  ... we have organized to oppose slavery, and enslavement of women, minorities, immigrants, workers.  
It was only during the depression when the question was asked whether we might be wrong in betting on the business community to get us through.  They crashed.  We could not blame anyone but the business class.  So we got social security.  And Unions came back some.  
   We imagine that once in the past we had the people being free ...  but really they were white males.  But that was our model.  Now we have ended slavery, opened doors of women, and regulatory agencies. ... but there is an ongoing desire to return to slaver, oppression of women.  But we are also on the precipice e of another Depression.  
   In NYTimes today, article about an Imam in a large mosque in Brooklyn.  jA liberal guy from Egypt.  Questions like, ³Islamic law and oral sex?²  He had a wonderful proverb: The Wall of hate has been build on insult after insult.  
   The liberal affluent are an endangered class.  We are frightened.  We are marginalized ourselves by our ignorance.  Neither big gov¹t nor big biz are our friends.  I have h ope in groups like this one where people can air their ideas.  People coming together.  Then fight against the commercial interests that are suffocating us.

Spencer:  Peter ³Work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion.²  However in later chapters. ... gov¹t agencies regulating biz; in constant communication; instead of regulating, they become friends.  So Peter thinks the agencies should be dissolved and reconstituted periodically.
   The Republicans have out thought us.  They have divided us in many ways.  We have internal fighting.  
   The Democrats shall rise again, if we play our cards well.

Mira liberals need to get together.  

Spencer: we have been outthought by the Hammas, by the Chinese, ...  We were so oblivious.  The system is broken.  

Mike  You gave a rich eloquent ramble, but loose ends.  Slavery didn¹t end it changed.  We got rid of chattel slavery and went into wage slavery.  Three eloquent American American figures who saw this before Marx.  Theophilus Fisk, of working men¹s mov¹t of 1840¹s; Orestes Brownson.  John C. Calhoun , vp for John Adams.  Defended slavery.  ³We treat our slaves well; we take care of them into old age.  You industrialists in the North throw your workers on the scrap heap when they are no longer productive.²  He was right.  
   ...people don¹t let t realize ... Soviet Union was not Communism.  An experiment that failed.

How do we get to economic democracy.  ... Capitalism has gone global.  
We want something that works for people.  ...live...raise our children ... good for humanity AND for the earth.  
   I am going to give a talk at Earthsave...  I am not worried; the Earth will save itself.  It will shrug, like with the disappearance of the dinosaurs.  The earth will probably eliminate humanity. ... I want to change the civilization.  Unless it can change it is not worth saving.  

   Go beyond the labels of liberalism.  Running out of oil, resources, and friends.  

Shari:  I am going to fold in the issue of the United Arab Emirates.  It is the same problem.  Remember Eisenhower warning about the military industrial complex s influence government That is we have now.  In Dubai we have the president, Bush, saying it would be OK for Dubai to run the ports in America .  Will veto the congress if they try to limit.  The conservatives say it is OK for the Dubai people manage our ports.  
   If  you look at this from the viewpoint of the influence of the military complex ... remember Helen Caldecott M.D. who said FEMA didn't work.  Could not save us from a nuclear attack; rather we m ust get rid of the nuclear threat.  She was right.  
   So this is not new.  

Chad  Such impassioned speaking.  Inspires me.  Encourages me to see what I can do.  
Kerry: this is good, I am learning a lot.

David: it is safe and easy to discuss these horrible problems.  It becomes hard and risky when you realize they are back door for  example the milk.  How many know there has been going on a two years strike, Cognis.  Don¹t provide health insur for their employees.  AK Steel has locked out their union.  
Health Dept finding out we have no say on our own garbage management, since it has been kicked out to the state level.  
   So these issues are in our own back yard.

Spencer:  Steve got me excited.  Second WW; social security and structures put in place to prevent poverty in old age for middle class.  ... end of WWII we were the only country in the west with industrial infrastructure in place still standing.  Since 1948 we have lived in the wealth from that... we squandered.  The ³Greatest Generation² are no longer around to remind u
   We discover that to sustain our wealth we have been selling off our assets.  The rich say ³Don¹t sell your underwear².  
We need to rethink our tax structure.
All regulatory agencies need to be reconstituted; become bedfellows with the industry they are regulating.  
   There are reasons for some regulations.  I have a niece who did not inoculate her children b ecause  ³those diseases are so rare, the risks are greater from inoculation itself.²  Fallacy... if everyone said that, ...  TB is back.  

Cheryl:  I have enjoyed everybody's thoughts.  

Jan: I am reading diamond¹s book Collapse about why civilizations end.  He looks at many cultures.  Unwitting destruction of your environment is one major cause.  Lead pipes and Rome.  The Romans were importing all their food.  Five major causes.  

Mira  Oscars last night.  the movie ³Crash².  Some of the people who made the movie and who acted in it seem to be showing truths that have never been brought out before.  ...a healing experience in making a truthful movie.  Racial issues.  ... People are listening to each other.  I have been studying buddhism lately... careful listening.  On ³Speaking of faith², Thich Nat Hahn interviewed last night.  He has some incredible answers to the only way we can stop fighting hatred with hatred, anger with anger.  All inhabitants of one earth home  I taped it.

Shari: Been reading the first Man, autobiog of Camus.  An French Algerian.  Parents died WWI.  Poverty.  Wonderful book.  Really struck me.  ³Poverty is a fortress without draw bridges.²  You can¹t get out.  Trapped.  We have no drawbridges into Washington; into Columbus.

Spencer:  Crash has no star.  Vignettes.  No WASP in the whole movie... no only one.  Theme, after all these incidents ... believable story , journey.  Interactions between people depend upon the circumstances.  You see the same guy being a devil and being a hero.  

Steve:  and no matter what you are doing, it is related to  world.  ay think we are only ten people, isolated... There are stories of hope and inspiration, of hopelessness and horror.  
The story of business sector oppression is our own story.  ³Crash² is wonderful because it shows the connectedness of so many different people.  

Mike:  beyond Syssiphis.  Every Monday we have a wonderful conversation and the following week there is almost no memory.  I hope we can talk next Mon. about Does  Intelligence matter?  Are we smart enough to change?  We are like frogs in a pot on a low flame... we don¹t jump out until it is too late.  

:



~ end of table notes ~



















Hugs to everyone,
Ellen

 













Section Two: Announcements



Richard Watson writes: Corryville  Community Meeting TUES, TONIGHT:

Our Think Tank Meeting will be held tomorrow 3/7/06 from 6-7:30pm. I am sorry for any confusion this may have cause for those not clear about the date and time. We will have 2 speakers, one from the Homestead Program to discuss property tax credits and another speaker to discuss the Home Improvement Program for property owners.

Here is what I said Sunday about that meeting:
At the Corryville Rec. Center, corner Eden and University in Corryville, at 6:00 - 7:30 pm
Think Tank" to discuss the "Uptown Consortium" plan for aggressive commercial development of this area.  Major players: U.C., Zoo.  
Community leaders in Corryville invite all interested neighbors in surrounding areas to discuss citizen participation.  One concern is the absence of low and middle income housing once these sweeping plans are implemented.  Where will the workers live who need to service hospitals, restaurants, etc.?  What about the elderly?  My contact  with this community org. is Richard Watson with services for the elderly in Corryville.

These developers are envisioning a continuation of the automobile boom of the previous decades.  I believe, however, that the days of the personal auto are numbered due to the soaring price of gas.  What we want is pedestrian-friendly, aesthetic localized villages of commerce and services.  

The Uptown Consortium wants to build a "Kenwood Town Center" of commercial development in the area between Vine and Ruether, opposite the pedestrian entrance of the Zoo, near the Veteran's Hospital.  A huge automobile retail etc. facility.  Sounds crazy to me.  Think of the traffic!  And what would that do to the businesses on Ludlow Ave?  

If you only go to one citizen's meeting this year, let it be (this one)

Ellen
P.S. MIKE RAMUNDO writes that his info says the new mall development will not be on top of the zoo parking lot, to his knowledge.  Someone  find out and get back to me.  e.





Lloyd House has Space Available





2/18/06  So  Matthew  has a new romance, so suddenly I have his beautiful space available as well as the small single on third floor.  I'd like either to find two  new housemates or else form a group who wants to co-own the property and live in a co-housing style here helping me to handle the maintenance and utilities.  

Matthew's 2 rooms on third floor. NE corner of house.  One E facing window, 2 small N facing windows.  Private full bath. Furnished with beautiful teak queen size bed and dresser, desk, wood and glass dining table for 4, coffee table, chaise longue, two beautiful dhurrie rugs.  Room adjoins spacious and beautiful zendo turret room used for meditation, yoga, drum circle, etc. Shares third floor kitchen with 3 other housemates. $420.
Jason's room, small single on third floor, one W facing window, double bed size suspended sleeping loft, large closet.  Bathroom right outside the door in the hall. Shares third floor kitchen with 3 other housemates. $350.
Also, first floor room for office, studio, ...?  This is a large oak paneled room with Rookwood fireplace.  Currently furnished with king size loft bed platform, sofa, arm chair, Dhurrie rug, long oak library table.  Could share the living room with me as a waiting room.  Has its own outside entry door.  A very handsome room.  Terrific for massage practice, for instance.  $320?
And come summer barring a miracle job for Alan in the city, we will have his beautiful two room suite available on second floor, plus sleeping porch.  
Other Perqs: off street parking, free laundry, high speed internet, living room with piano, TV, DVD, VCR, community iMac Computer.  Dining room seats 16+.  Veranda off dining room with Hatteras swing, furniture.  Easy access to Monday night salon pot luck, Saturday morning Dharma Study group, Sat. evening drumming circle, and ....
The Lloyd House is a stimulating, friendly, multi-cultural environment.  Good vibes are required, as is a rock solid financial responsibility.  Housemates can be as private or as friendly as they wish.  Know anyone who might like to explore this?  No undergraduates, no pets, no smoking.  Prefer someone who would be interested in participating in the Salon and/or other activities here.  Call me: 221 1289  

P.S.  It feels like something new might be about to happen with regard to the use of the Lloyd House.  Help me dream that up.  221 1289  or email   Ellen   ellenbierhorst@lloydhouse.com
2/26




Hey Lloyd House Drumming Circle!




At our weekly Sat. night drumming circle we have a blast.  Djembes, other drums, shakers of all descriptions, flute, recorder, animal sounds (!), Dancing, .. now trying it on the first floor where we can also use the grand piano and won't have to schlep drums up to the third floor.  Come!

Just two hours, not long, refreshing, healing, ... Come join in this.  

Love and kisses,
Ellen

Please Note this:
if you have an email list of drumming people (or dance people, or chant people or instrumental improv. people ... folks who would love this) would you please send this announcement to them and ...
If you  are getting this announcement SECOND HAND from a friend, not from me, Ellen, would you PLEASE send me an email
ellenbierhorst@lloydhouse.com
and ask to be subscribed to the drum list?  Just send an empty email message and put in the SUBJECT LINE the words "subscribe drum".  




...............................................................................








OK, so get yourself here ( 3901 Clifton Ave, Cinti.) Saturday, and any/every Saturday night at 7 pm.  Let's keep t his building.  Keep happy during winter.  Heal yourself.  
   Love and beats,
Ellen

Logistics: Lloyd House 3901 Clifton Avenue zip 45220, use mapquest.com if you don't know your way here.  Park on Lafayette ave. after unloading drums.  Do NOT block the driveway.  Remove shoes in foyer. Walk up rear stairs (pass the big front staircase) to third floor.  Bring snacks or drinks if you like.  Bring love and good vibes, any musical instruments or any kind, etc. etc.  All children welcome.  



03/07/2006:

Since silliness is a Jewish religious obligation for the Feast of Esther (Purim), come to
UC Hillel's Annual Latke-Hamantash Debate  
Tuesday, March 7th @ noon.


Witness the passion felt for Jewish foods, as Dr. Jason Kalman of HUC
battles Dr. Yonatan Eyal from the history department at UC to determine
which Jewish food rocks in this Purim extravaganza. Free lunch (including
Jewish treats) for all students, $5 for community members. RSVP to Jessica
at jessica@hillelcincinnati.org  <mailto:jessica@hillelcincinnati.org> .


3/7 -  1 1


Women¹s History Month 2006   women's FILM FESTIVAL


Tuesday March 7, 2006                                                                                                                7:00pm ­ 9:00pm                                                                                                                              Women¹s Networking Panel                                                                                                          400 A B C TUC                                                                                                                              Co-sponsored by Sigma Phi, Student Government and Mainstreet

Come network with successful women who work in the Cincinnati area. Join us for an open forum of questions and answers from some of Cincinnati¹s leading women.

Victoria Morgan - Artistic Director for the Cincinnati Ballet                                             Ashley Young- Director of Communication for Cincinnati Area Chapter American Red Cross                    

Jennifer Manders- Physician UC Cancer Research Center/ The Barrett Center        

Linda Bates Parker- Director of UC Career Development Center

Barbara Rinto- Director of UC Women's Center                                                                        Evelyn Collazzo- Director of Medical Education in Sales Training & Development, Ethicon Endo Surgery Institute                                                                                               

Rebecca Fellers- Owner of Rebecca Fellers Interiors

Barb Link- Consulting Engineer General Electric











Women¹s History Month 2006 (continued)



Wednesday March 8, 2006                                                                                                                    12:00pm ­ 2:00pm                                                                                                                 International Women¹s Day: Food for Thought                                                                            Silenced Shame: The Fistula Debate                                                                                                571 Steger Student Life

The WHO (World Health Organization) has called fistula ³the single most dramatic aftermath of neglected childbirth². In addition to complete incontinence, a fistula victim may develop nerve damage to the lower extremities after a multi-day labor in a squatting position. Fistula victims also suffer profound psychological trauma resulting from their utter loss of status and dignity. Too few people know about obstetric fistula and the tragedy it brings to approximately 100,000 women each year. It is estimated that there are 100,000 new fistula cases each year, but the international capacity to treat fistula remains at only 6,500 per year. Join us in discussing the plight of women living with obstetric fistula, the most devastating aftermath of unattended childbirth.

Thursday March 30, 2006                                                                                                     5:00pm ­ 7:00pm                                                                                                                                Iron Jawed Angels Film Viewing and Discussion                                                                                 571 Steger Student Life

Katja von Garnier's "Iron Jawed Angels" tells the remarkable and little-known story of a group of passionate and dynamic young women, who put their lives on the line to fight for American women's right to vote. This true story has startling parallels to today, as the young activists struggle with issues such as the challenges of protesting a popular President during wartime and the perennial balancing act between love and career.


Profiles of Outstanding Women Faculty, Staff, and Students displayed in TUC Atrium and the Women¹s Center throughout the month of March

patricia.carroll@uc.edu





3/8    Green Construction Expo




³The one place where the entire industry can meet to discover and share leading edge ideas, applications and technology²

Wednesday March 8, 2006     Sharonville Convention Center

Product Show: 5:00 pm ­ 8:30 pm    Workshops: 1:00 pm ­ 5:00 pm

Construction Products Showcase
Presented by:
The Cincinnati Chapter of
The Construction Specifications
Institute

Free Admission

Door Prizes All Night
Free Food and Beverages
$1000 Grand Prize!

(Must be present to win)

Join hundreds of industry professionals at The 27th Annual CSI Construction Products Showcase, as you experience growth in product and professional knowledge, and benefit from networking with your peers.
See, touch, and learn about the latest products and technology from more than 100 of the industry¹s leading companies.  They¹ll discuss business and technology advances and look for ways to help you become more efficient and profitable.
Select your targets, chart your course, leave room for discovery, stop and ask, and chose your literature carefully. We are sure your visit to The CSI Construction Products Showcase will be profitable and rewarding.

Also at Construct CincinnatiŠ

Most Innovative Building Practices
VisionaryProductSolutions, Inc
8:30 am -12:30 pm
and
The ACI Annual Meeting
Contact AIA Cincinnati for details


BuildGreen Workshops
Presented by
The Committee on the Environment of the Cincinnati Chapter of the American Institute of Architects and the Ohio/Kentucky Chapter of the International Interior Design Association
1:00 pm ­ 2:00 pm
High Performance Workspace
Haworth
The economic and design viability of creating environmentally sustainable commercial office interiors
Advanced Exterior Wall Systems and Moisture Control
Centria
The key performance criteria for advanced exterior wall construction, how the design and construction rules are changing, and how metal cladding systems can provide excellent performance and moisture control
2:15 pm ­ 3:15 pm
Investing in Sustainable Interior Environments
Lees Carpet
Current sustainable design practices and concepts and methods to develop healthy interior environments
Daylighting Research and Design
Advanced Glazings
Current research methods and findings to successfully incorporate daylighting design
3:30 pm ­ 5:00 pm
Peeling back the Ecolabel
Scientific Certification Systems (SCS)
Evaluating environmental claims, the truths and myths behind the countless eco-labels in today¹s market and advantages of obtaining third-party product certification
Register to Attend the Green Build Workshops
through AIA Cincinnati.
Contact Pat Daugherty
by phone at (513) 421-4661
by email at  aiacinti@fuse.net
or go to  www.aiacincinnati.org.
Workshop Registration
$25.00 (pre-registered)  
$30.00 (at the door)
Student attendance is free.  
Register now and save!




3/11  This event achieves Lift Off every year.  Linda Tillery is a hurricane!  ellen


Muse: New Spirituals Concert
Cathy Roma, Muse,
w/ Linda Tillery
March 10, 11
8:pm at House of Joy in College Hill



Tickets $15  online: musechoir.org
Shakit Records in Northside




Local Forest Habitat Restoration Events

Burnet Woods   March 11th       9:00 to 1:00   Meet at Trailside Nature Center  -   Info. Steve 961-7711


Green Up Day and Great American Cleanup combined   April 22   Burnet Woods
Info. Cindi Nugent 861-8970

Rawson Woods April 29, 10-12. garlic mustard pull and trash clean up. Meet your neighbors at the corner of Middleton and McAlpin. Info. Joy at 221-8285.
All events are with the Cincinnati Park Board.
Dress for the weather, bring your own water, and gloves.
Questions?  ask  Steve Slack  slack@fuse.net





2/25

Scorecard: The Pollution Information Site
Concerned about issues with your water and air?
Enter your Zip code at
http://www.scorecard.org/
This will alert you to the major polluters in your area.
See also information on chemicals, watersheds, superfund sites, and animal wastes.
And then ask yourself, "What am I doing to make this situation better or worse?"
Blessings



END THE WAR
STOP THE NEXT ONE NOW

Rally and March

Sunday, March 19, 2006
2pm
Burnet Woods Lone Star Pavilion
(off Clifton Ave. directly across from Hebrew Union College)
Sponsored by the Intercommunity Justice and Peace Center

Peaceful, legal, family-friendly event

Many people in the United States now question whether the war ever
should have happened, and calls for withdrawal of all U.S. troops from
Iraq are growing. People are demanding the truth .

We are making a difference.
We are going to end this war.

Make your voice heard on Sunday, March 19 ,in
solidarity with people across the nation!

For more info , call 513-579-8547
or see www.ijpc-cincinnati.org






3/11
Sing Along at Ginny Frazer's / Steve Shoemaker's:
Bring songbooks, food or drink to share as we celebrate Women’s Herstory Month thru Song at Steve & Ginny’s 1539 Glen Parker Avenue (Off Hamilton Ave. in Northside). Potluck at 7:00, singing starts at 7:30 or so. Please RSVP or call 513-541-5361.
(This is my type of thing.  Unfortunately, I'll be in Denver visiting my daughter!  ellen)




3/20 Cincinnatian and Muslim American leader Karen Dabdoub to join us at the Salon Table on Monday 3/20 to answer common stereotypes and dialogue with us.  Be there!



4/8


SPAN Ohio to sponsor all day conference on
Single Payer Health Care for Ohioans




Sat. April 8   10 am  to 4 pm
Holiday Inn City Center  175 E. Town St.  (614-221-3281)
Columbus, OH

This is the group that Dr. Don Rucknagel supports, the doc. who gave us that great power point presentation a couple of weeks ago.  Let's throw our energy behind this initiative.  I am looking to form a car pool-drive up and back same day.  Call me, ellen: 221 1289.

To register ($15 fee, includes lunch) see
www.spanohio.org or email spanhealthcare@aol.com

SPAN Ohio tidbit: Myth: "Universal Health Car will cost too much." Reality: not more, less!  25 to 30 cents of every dollar spent on health care currently goes to  the insurance companies and HMOs.  Compare this with only 2.9 cents for every health dollar that goes to Medicare.  Look at that difference!   If those billions were used for patient care instead of to the insurance and HMO companies, that would provide much of the funding required to cover the medical needs of all Ohioans.   Learn more at
www.spanohio.org



3/18

The third anniversary of war in Iraq is fast approaching. People around the United States and world are organizing  . . . The tide is turning!!!!

The majority of people in the United States now question whether the war ever should have happened, and calls for withdrawal of all U.S. troops from Iraq are growing. People are demanding the truth .We are making a difference. We are going to end this war. Join us!

There will be a statewide antiwar rally and march in Columbus on Saturday, March 18 and a local spirited anti-war arlly and march on Sunday March 19 at Burnet Woods Lone Star Pavilion. More details below…Also, find some information about an important march from Mobile, AL to New Orleans being organized by Veterans for Peace and others .


MARCH 18, 2006    
STATEWIDE RALLY AND MARCH TO STOP THE WAR IN IRAQ
2:00-3:00 pm.  
Marchers gather at 12:30 at the Ohio Statehouse, Columbus, OH.


http://www.cpanews.org/march18/  
Planning on going to Columbus on March 18th?
Need a ride or willing to take someone along?
IJPC will be happy to help make the connections for you. Call kristen at 513-579-8547or email kristen@ijpc-cincinnati.org

Sun, MARCH 19
END THE WAR STOP THE NEXT ONE Rally and March
(on the third anniversary of war in Iraq in solidarity with events happening around the world)
2pm
Burnet Woods Lone Star Pavilion (on Clifton Ave. directly across from Hebrew Union College)
Peaceful, legal, family friendly event.
Sponsored by the Intercommunity Justice and Peace Center
Download flyer and handbills at http://www.ijpc-cincinnati.org/
For more information, contact kristen@ijpc-cincinnati.org or call at 513-579-8547

VETERANS’ AND SURVIVORS’ MARCH FOR PEACE AND JUSTICE
March 14-19, 2006
Mobile to New Orleans
EVERY BOMB DROPPED IN IRAQ EXPLODES OVER NEW ORLEANS
Veterans For Peace (VFP), Iraq Veterans Against the War (IVAW), Vietnam Veterans Against the War (VVAW), Military Families Speak Out (MFSO), and Gold Star Families for Peace (GSFP), at the call of the Mobile Veterans For Peace Chapter #130, will conduct a march between Mobile, AL, and New Orleans, LA, from March 14-19, 2006 -- the third anniversary of the invasion and occupation of Iraq.
This historical event highlights the connections between the economic and human cost of war in the Middle East and the failure of our government to respond to human needs at home, especially the needs of poor people and people of color.

The government's negligent and often hostile response to hurricane survivors is mirrored by that same government's continued commitment to an illegal, immoral war fought at a staggering cost.
These are twin disasters, and the veterans of wars abroad along with the survivors of Katrina and Rita are joining together for this march and caravan to establish ties of material solidarity between those who oppose the war abroad and the social and economic costs for working people at home.
http://www.vetgulfmarch.org/index.php



Section Three: Articles




Contents:

  • "Assault" of law enforcement people on milk farmer in Winton Place Today!
  • Peace demonstration April 29, New York City
  • Todd Portune on The Banks project; mystification clarified.










3/7/06
For over a year I have been participating in the Cow Share program, whereby Ky. dairyman Gary Oaks keeps cows that I and my fellow share owners do legally own.  He then milks the cows and brings our milk to Winton place for drop off.  This is raw milk.  Monday, yesterday, I was told by several eye witnesses that law enforcement persons came to assail Gary, confiscated his milk, upset him badly, and he fell down with a  heart attack and was rushed to University Hospital.  Below, a fellow cow share owner, Dan, says more:

Gary Oaks had a heart attack today. It happened when the US FDA, the
Ohio Department of Agriculture, the Ky Department of Agriculture, and
the Hamilton County Sheriff's Department delivered a seize and desist
order in a raid on the milk delivery to the Cincinnati Waldorf School's
parking lot. The order stated that the state could seize all the milk
owned by the Oaks'. Well, none of the milk belongs to the Oaks'. It
belongs to us, the cow herd's rightful and contractual owners. No one
stepped up to say that they owned the milk, but that doesn't change the
fact that it is ours. All of our milk and milk products were taken. The
Oaks' have been ordered to stop their operation (wait, it's our
operation...).

What should we do? How should the cows' owners respond? We should
respond together. I have been volunteered to head this effort to respond
unless someone else feels strongly called to do this.

OK. I want to have a straightforward response to all this. If we fly off
the cuff we can look emotional, and the media loves to make emotional
folks look crazy. Please let others in the program know that we need to
respond together. If people want to say anything, it should simply be
that Dawn and Gary don't even own the cows, we do. The government seized
our milk, not the Oaks', and the response should stop there for now.

Do you know if we have any share owners who are attorneys? The seizure
of our milk was clearly illegal. The writ was written so that it was a
seizure of the Oaks' property, and the milk and bottles do not belong to
them.

Let us quickly collect our resources and then make a response that
really makes sense, both to the common man and to the judge. Let me know
what ideas or expectations you have.

Peace,

Dan Burwinkel



2/18


Next Major Peace Demonstration in D.C.
April 29




PEACE, JUSTICE, FREEDOM, THE EARTH: JOINING THEM ON APRIL 29



For the first time, an important part of the environmental movement and an important part of the antiwar movement, as well as the National Organization for Women and others, are joining to bring an end to  "global scorching" and the Iraq War as well as to end attacks on the Constitution and on the poor and the middle class by the present US government.

This broad coalition is calling for a major march in New York City on April 29.

Says the call to this march:

·      No more never-ending oil wars!   
·      Protect our civil liberties & immigrant rights, and end illegal  spying, government corruption and the subversion of our democracy.   
·      Rebuild our communities, starting with the Gulf Coast. Stop corporate  subsidies and tax cuts for the wealthy while ignoring our basic needs.
·      Act quickly to address the climate crisis and the accelerating destruction  of our environment.

Among the initiating groups are ---
United for Peace and Justice
NOW
Rainbow/PUSH Coalition
US Labor Against the War
Friends of the Earth
Climate Crisis Coalition
Peoples Hurricane Relief Fund

Readers of The Shalom Report will be especially interested to know that UPJ has decided to refuse any further alliances with "ANSWER" in organizing any demonstrations, etc.

The UPJ steering committee did this by a two-thirds majority,  out of its experience both of deep political differences between ANSWER & UPJ  in organizing  the antiwar actions last September, and of serious failures by ANSWER to adhere to and carry out commitments the two groups had agreed to beforehand.

You may recall that The Shalom Center was so indignant about the involvement of the bitterly anti-Israel ANSWER in the September 24 antiwar rally that we held an independent  pro-peace Shabbat service during the rally time of that weekend,and then took part in other aspects of the weekend when ANSWER had no role.

Now we can take whole-hearted part, especially since our other concerns ­ Oil, Global Scorching, the US Constitution ­ are also on the agenda.

###################

The Climate Crisis Coalition has just installed a Climate Crisis News Engine on its website (www.climatecrisiscoalition.org).  Each morning from its various ³newsfeeds,² CCC identifies a dozen or so stories to post on the site.  They get rotated on the home page.  (To see all the stories click Climate Crisis News Engine

http://www.climatecrisiscoalition.org/climatenews/


###########
Shalom, Arthur

Rabbi Arthur Waskow, director
The Shalom Center www.shalomctr.org voices a new prophetic agenda in Jewish, multireligious, and American life. To receive the weekly on-line Shalom Report, click on --
http://www.shalomctr.org/subscribe




3/4/ Salonista and Cincinnati activist Jenny Edwards sends in this on
Todd Portune talks about the Banks

Dear Friends, Hamilton Countians/Cincinnatians:
Many times the subject of THE BANKS stirs up a whirl because the
 
historical understanding, including the players and motivators/detractors, seem to change on the scorecard weekly. A history of confusion on a local matter(s) has never been greater.
A little past 2 pm today the Dean of Cincinnati posted the following BANKS PRESENTATION by one of our most candid and clear voices, Hamilton County Commissioner Todd Portune. Link to www.cincinnatibeacon.com <http://www.cincinnatibeacon.com>  in order to both read and come to a clearer understanding of what is faced on many fronts by the elected officials in this matter. This airing out of the overall matter is long needed.
Thanks, Todd for creating this presentation and challenging us to learn from it.
 
Sincerely,
 
Jenny Edwards
 


The Cincinnati Beacon <http://www.cincinnatibeacon.com/index.php>   

The Banks: Presentation by Commissioner Todd Portune <http://www.cincinnatibeacon.com/index.php/magaddiction/comments/the_banks_presentation_by_commissioner_todd_portune/>
Thursday, March 02, 2006
The Cincinnati Beacon

The Banks: Presentation by Commissioner Todd Portune
Thursday, March 02, 2006

Posted by The Dean of Cincinnati

Guest column by County Commissioner Todd Portune

Introduction
To understand why the City of Cincinnati and Hamilton County have encountered such difficulty in getting the mega-project known as The Banks off the ground requires a detailed understanding of the entire history of the project. Too many statements, positions, opinions and postures have been taken and written that evidence a misunderstanding of where we are and why we are where we are on this project.

There are very few people involved in orchestrating the approach to the project today who were intimately involved with it at the beginning. From the standpoint of elected officials, there are only two ­ Hamilton County Commissioners Phil Heimlich and Todd Portune. It is not surprising then that in many key respects, including the all-important approach toward financing of the project, both Phil and I are virtually aligned. As will be demonstrated throughout this document how we finance this project; what resources are used; where they come from; who has what responsibility; and the like, will determine our ability to get the project done.

The lack of institutional memory has, to many degrees, proven to be problematic and has resulted in a number of missteps by the bodies of government and in various misinterpretations by the public, all of which have helped to contribute to delays; strained relationships; and increased costs. In order to move ahead however it is important that we acknowledge the past and facts of history.

But to get the project done also demands that all of the present day parties to the effort candidly, honestly and accurately discuss and acknowledge the present day realities that impact our collective ability to get the project done. This includes more than the governmental bodies of the Cincinnati City council and Hamilton County. It includes the Port Authority of Cincinnati and Hamilton County. It includes the opinion shapers and editorial Board writers at the Cincinnati Enquirer, Cincinnati Post, Cincinnati Business Courier and The Herald. It includes key business leaders individually and collectively through such organizations as the Cincinnati Business Committee, the Cincinnati Center City Development Company (3CDC). It includes Cincinnati¹s two most recognizable citizens ­ the Cincinnati Reds and the Cincinnati Bengals. And lastly it includes those Developer voices that have consistently either been a part of the evolution of this project, or have expressed an interest in being a part of the project, such as Bill Butler, Rob Smyjunas, Neal and Arn Bortz, Tom Humes and Jack Rouse.

The various issues and complexities to the project are larger than the ability or capacity of any single individual or entity to control. It is for that reason that I have been outwardly critical of the various efforts by our Board President to try to handle the negotiations and process in a manner that is characterized as largely a secret one involving only Mayor Mallory, Commissioner Heimlich and respective staffers to both of their offices.

The posture adopted by Commission President Heimlich is not representative of the entire Commission nor can it be considered to be representative of the county.
Phil has No authority.
Has been given no parameters.
We have not, as a Board, met to determine what our approach will be, nor have we voted to accept or reject any proposal or posture etc..

Accordingly, it is a process that has been doomed to failure from the start. It has bred distrust. It has allowed exterior forces to gain undue leverage in shaping the debate. It will, unless immediately reversed, run the risk of scuttling the ability of City and County to put the project together in a way that maximizes the positive potential of The Banks and does so in a way that keeps taxpayer¹s costs and risk to minimal levels.

In the Beginning:
In the beginning there was no such thing as The Banks project. The existing documents evidence a clear understanding of the relationship between the city and the county to be this: The County was to build stadiums while the city was to do the development around the stadiums. The City had an economic development department ­ county did not. The City held the development rights ­ county did not. The City owned much of the land while the County did not. And the City held control over the all-important Air Rights above the ³podium² in the Banks area of development.

In 1996 the Stadium Sales Tax was placed on the ballot with the intent of covering the cost of two stadiums and the cost of building both the public infrastructure and public parking to support the activities that would be hosted by the two stadiums. The total cost of two stadiums and parking was slated to be $544 Million. The tax was declared by public officials and supporters of the project to be a sales tax that would be eliminated in no more than 20 years.

Those parameters of the cost of the project and the bright line defining responsibilities of the city and the county got blurred over time. But to understand The Banks and the difficulties the city and the county face today we must begin with this basic understanding of the stadium sales tax and of ³who was going to do what.²

After the Stadium Sales Tax passed in March of 1996, the city, in the Fall of 1996, expressed its interest in developing the riverfront with more than just stadiums. The county¹s original plan was to rebuild one stadium on top of Cinergy Field and build the other stadium just to the west of the Roebling Suspension Bridge. [See the attached initial rendering of the two stadiums, attached] However, by building two stadiums next to one another at the location of the Suspension Bridge made it readily apparent that to do that would have resulted in nothing other than stadiums being developed along the river. In essence the city would be walled off from the rest of the world with stadiums.

This lead to the creation of the Riverfront Advisors. Don Carter and UDA Associates from Pittsburgh Pa. came in the fall of 1996 and presented several concepts of what could happen. Those concepts included one in which the baseball stadium or football stadium would be built at Broadway commons. UDA Associates also presented a concept known as the ³Big Bang² theory, which had the stadiums, spread apart and all sorts of development crammed in between them.

The City rejected the Big Bang ­ too much public money would be spent. The general theory was that once the basic infrastructure was in place the opportunity should be great enough that any developer would want to make it worth its while in that this would become the most attractive land for development purposes in the Midwest if not the country. In other words, the feeling of the elected officials in 1997 and thereafter was that spending public money to build the public infrastructure of parking and streets and the like was all that should be required of taxpayers. The private development opportunities at the location of the Banks are so extraordinary that private developers should come in with their own financing for the so-called private development.

There has been no formal reversal of that policy at any time by either the City of Cincinnati or by Hamilton County.

The Riverfront Advisors became the Port Authority. The Port Authority was created via Resolutions and Ordinances that were passed into law in the Fall of 2000. The Port was an entity created, in part, for the purpose of removing some of the ³political² influences from the process. Nonetheless the creation of the Port Authority was surrounded with all kinds of political influences, and remains so today.

The Port Authority also came into being with great emphasis placed upon its ability to capture or access dollars and savings that purportedly could not be realized via existing governmental structures. That, too, remains the unaltered policy of the city and the county regarding the need for, and usefulness of, the Port Authority and its involvement in this project.

The elimination of those overriding features quite frankly eliminates the need for the Port Authority to oversee The Banks.

Why Has Almost Six Years Gone By With Little Discernable Progress?
During this time, of the Riverfront Advisors and then the creation of the Port Authority, the city and the county met regularly in what was known as the City-County Riverfront Steering Committee. It was comprised of all three county commissioners and the city¹s Intergovernmental Affairs, Environment and Development Committee plus the Mayor. A total of 7 representatives from the city were officially a part of the Committee, though all 9 Members of City Council could attend any meeting. The Committee worked at attaining ³consensus² on all issues. I don¹t recall a single instance where there was a roll call vote on a matter.

The City County Steering Committee met dozens of times through 2000. Despite calls to do the same, no meetings were held and no reasons were ever given for the failure to meet. The last effort at scheduling a meeting failed in November 2001. An agenda was prepared for that meeting; it was continued several times; and then people simply quit trying to re-schedule.

I would argue the failure to meet is one of the reasons why there have been delays in advancing the Banks. The reality is that during the time frame when the Steering Committee met the city and the county entered into an era of considerable cooperation on some of the most problematic and thorny issues imaginable. The committee ushered in a new standard of cooperation that directly resulted in the development of a plan for The Banks and the adoption of the same.

There were numerous concerns and hurdles along the way but they were all worked out. None ever rose to the level of being an absolute deal breaker and you actually got the sense that no matter what the issue it would be worked out because we were committed to doing so. The very public meetings that were attended by all of the parties and that were closely scrutinized by the news media put all of the elected officials under the gun to work together and not hold up progress. The openness and transparency of the process demanded that we work every thing out.

And then that all ended.

I do not know why then Mayor Luken and Commissioners Dowlin, Neyer, and now Heimlich, have never called for such a meeting to take place. I know that I did, repeatedly. I don¹t know where Mayor Mallory sits on the issue. But the reality is that since 2000 there hasn¹t been a joint session of the city and the county working together on a common agenda of riverfront related issues and I would argue that the lack of progress on the Banks speaks volumes to what the failure to convene such a session has wrought.

With Money All Things are Possible
Given the lack of structured cooperation all other factors that have contributed to delay in starting The Banks, or to problems in accomplishing it, have become magnified. Perhaps no single problem is greater than the lifeblood issue of the effort that involves money and whether there exists adequate financing to complete the project. So far there has been a concern about whether there exists adequate funding to do the same. Key reasons for the concerns are:

The Demands on the Stadium Sales Tax have substantially exceeded what was originally intended. This is perhaps the one area where the biggest source of financial difficulty has been created. At present, and in order to meet all existing financial obligations that are being paid out of, and supported by, the one-half cent stadium sales tax adopted by the voters of Hamilton County in 1996, the county is facing a $191 Million present value deficit over the life of the obligation. Let¹s go back to what was promised. The sales tax was designed to pay for $544 Million of capital improvements that was broken down as $460 Million for two new stadiums and $80 Million for the necessary and related public parking and public infrastructure to support the stadiums. The tax was also designed to support the county¹s half of the joint city and county pledge to Cincinnati Public Schools that was to raise $200 Million over 20 years for the schools¹ capital building construction and rehabilitation needs. The tax also was designed to provide a rollback to county property tax payers.

After the fact, however, several things occurred that were different from what had been discussed and what people relied upon when making their decisions, not the least of which were the voters who went to the polls. First, the city and the county overreached by deciding to spend the sales tax money on virtually anything related to the riverfront. Any time an issue came up about the riverfront and there was a need for money the stadium sales tax one-half cent came up as the answer. This included, among other things, paying for the cost of land for stadium construction [we¹ll get into the amount in a minute] and the cost of the decking over Fort Washington Way.

The schools overreached as well. I know it may not be politically popular to discuss this issue but the reality is the Cincinnati Public Schools are currently receiving about twice as much stadium sales tax money from Hamilton County than what was originally contemplated. In 1995 and 1996 when the city and county elected leaders met to develop the Memorandum of Understanding between the city an county around the whole stadium issue and the sales tax, both sides were looking to develop a revenue stream that would raise about $5 Million a year from both the city and the county. Such a revenue stream would produce a total of $200 Million collectively from the city and the county over twenty years. The purpose of the money was to cover the debts service on bonds that would be issued to raise money for repairing the aging facility infrastructure of Cincinnati Public Schools. As of today CPS is receiving $5 Million per year from the city. Over twenty years that will yield $100 Million from the city. But when the stadiums had cost overruns, and when the land needed to construct the football stadium was overpaid for, the school system obtained a windfall of over a $100 Million increase in payment. Again, it is undoubtedly political unpopular to discuss reforming this arrangement to be consistent with the original intent. Many will argue that they would prefer the schools get money instead of stadiums, or developments like the Banks. But I think it is fair to raise the issue especially when the Cincinnati Public Schools facilities master plan has undergone several revisions downward in terms of scope and cost with those downturns reducing the amount of money the State of Ohio contributes and reducing the money CPS is contributing. While every other aspect of the plan is a reduction in dollar amount is it fair for county taxpayers¹ obligation to increase? Is it fair for such an increase to occur when we are faced with the financial uncertainty of the Banks? And is it not better to modify the capital dollars contributed by the county here because of the demands on the sales tax revenue stream instead of considering a corresponding reduction in human services funding that is general fund supported for children¹s services because the general fund will have to make up a sales tax shortfall that is due, in part, to this schools¹ facilities capital fund windfall?

The landowners of the property needed for the football stadium received about $70 Million for floodplain property that had been valued at less than $10 Million by the County Auditor Dusty Rhodes. A close examination of the land purchase reveals that it was not the result of an objective eminent domain court proceeding or arms length transaction. Instead the purchase of the land, and the price paid for it, was a sweetheart deal reached between the county and the property owners (who just so happened to be represented by the law firm of the then Chairman of the local GOP).

The Teams have also benefited beyond original expectations. The Reds, while having been great to work with, still received a stadium that was paid for by taxpayers to the tune of $40 Million more than envisioned when the sales tax went to vote. Admittedly, however, when the report was issued by Don Carter and UDA Associates on January 16, 1997 about possible locations for stadiums and their respective costs, the Reds Stadium did not go up a penny in price. It was pegged back then to come in at $281 Million. The final cost to taxpayers upon completion in 2003 was $280 Million, or $1 Million less than the Carter/UDA estimate. The Bengals, on the other hand, in addition to all of the stadium lease elements and obligations, received a stadium that, together with land costs, was $254 Million more than its estimated cost when the sales tax was voted upon in 1996. Carter and UDA¹s estimate, including the cost of all of the riverfront land needed to be bought, was $251 Million, or about $200 Million less than the actual cost of the stadium.

The Bengals, when they sold the Charter Ownership Agreements, told their fans and prospective purchasers that their purchase of a COA would yield money for the cost of the stadium ³on top of² an existing Bengals contribution of between $44 Million and $48 Million. [copy of the Bengals¹ developed and approved script available on request] There has been no such contribution in those amounts made by the Bengals to apply against the cost of building Paul Brown Stadium.

The Bengals have also said repeatedly that they wanted a Baltimore style arrangement and that they have been, somehow, aggrieved for not having received such. Attached to this paper is a letter dated June 1, 1995 from the Maryland Stadium Authority, first seen by the county when it was obtained during discovery in the county¹s litigation with the Team, that details the Baltimore deal. A close examination of the letter reveals the many ways in which Hamilton County taxpayers [and accordingly the county¹s available resources for The Banks] have suffered diminished resources under the existing arrangement with the team in contrast to what taxpayers would have had the Team been willing to simply be satisfied with a Baltimore Style agreement. The county would likely gladly reform its arrangement with the team to be equal to the Baltimore deal and should ask that the city join in asking for a reformation of the deal in an effort to aid in the completion of the Banks.

The enormity of the above alterations to the original concept envisioned by planners and leaders alike when the Stadium Sales Tax was proposed has been substantial and impacts considerably the ability of city and county both to complete The Banks. Modification of any, all, or some combination thereof, will contribute greatly to our ability at this stage to complete The Banks in the manner and form appropriate to the magnitude of the opportunity the Development provides.

A simple recap reveals that over $562 Million is at stake.

Cost of Stadiums: Originally contemplated to total $460 Million. UDA Associates Plan [land included] $$531 Million. Actual cost of both stadiums: $734 Million. Differential to sales tax: $274 Million more expensive;

Lost contribution to cost of stadium from the Bengals due to lack of full realization of Team capital contribution: $48 - $73 Million;

Baltimore Style Arrangement: County loses a minimum of over $7 Million per year. Total for twenty years: $140 Million, minimum.

Incremental Demands on Sales Tax. The total capital costs originally slated to be covered by the sales tax was $544 Million. To date it exceeds $940 Million. Total cost to taxpayers of incremental costs are over $400 Million.

Windfall PILOT Payments to CPS. The dollars being raised from both the City of Cincinnati and Hamilton County for the capital infrastructure needs of Cincinnati public Schools were designed to cover debts service on $200 Million of improvements to be paid off over twenty years. The CPS Facilities master Plan has already been downsized several times with the most recent downsizing having been just announced within the past week. With each downsizing the amount paid by CPS and by the State of Ohio [which has primary responsibility] has been reduced. Hamilton County Taxpayers¹ contribution, however, has increased in real dollars and substantially increased as a percentage of the whole. With the recent announcement county taxpayer¹s percentage share will dramatically increase as it comes at a time when, unless adjusted, county taxpayers¹ gross contribution will double from about $100 Million to over $200 Million. Impact to county sales taxes available for riverfront development such as the banks is a loss of over $100 Million.

The total impact of the altered landscape from what was originally contemplated is an incremental burden on the Stadium Sales Tax in excess of $562 Million.

Downturn in sales tax collections; By now it is common knowledge that the percentage rate of collections of the one-half cent stadium sales tax have not met projected levels that were relied upon by the county. Taxes were projected to rise at a 3% rate per annum. They have averaged less than 1% and this year are tracking, again, at less than 1% [January 2006 came in at -0.43%] the actual figures are attached.

Stadium cost overruns and increases in price; I don¹t need to belabor the point. But as the attached articles demonstrate the original sales tax and discussions were based upon a capital budget for two stadiums and related parking of $544 Million. The stadiums ballooned to $734 Million while the parking has yet to be completed

Cost of land for stadium development; for example, one of the parcels of land was valued by the auditor in the neighborhood of $7 Million to $10 Million was ultimately settled for at over $35 Million. Total land purchase was in excess of $70 Million with the same kind of consideration applying.

Parking guarantees and revenue implications; Hamilton County has already paid $62 Million for Parking improvements and enhancements to serve the riverfront along with the needs of the Reds and the Bengals. The total infrastructure needed to support The Banks exceeds $200 Million. In addition to the capital costs are revenue guarantees to the Bengals. At several times over the past five years plans to jump-start The Banks were evaluated. At each stage the Lease issues between the county and the Bengals over parking revenue guarantees became a financial impediment. The costs of these issues invariably totaled between $4 Million on the low side to as much as $10 Million on the high side. In one scenario the County was required to contemplate purchasing property for the purpose of providing alternate temporary parking at a cost of between $10 Million and $15 Million. Regardless of the approach the city and county must resolve the financial implications of the parking revenue guarantees upon the financial ability of the city and the county to construct The Banks. Absent reforming the existing lease with the Bengals on this issue adds costs to the cost of completing the Banks without getting anything of value in return. It potentially takes away dollars that are needed to cover the cost of other features of the banks, including the Public Park, or the decking over Fort Washington Way.

The economy; the general state of the economy has had a tremendous impact upon the generation of revenues that the county needs to rely upon for the Banks ­ especially sales taxes. There is no doubt that the Nation slid into a recession in 2001 with Ohio being one of the hardest hit states, losing over 250,000 manufacturing jobs alone in the last four years. The impact of the economy upon sales tax collections is reflected in the document attached.

Nine Eleven. September 11, 2001 is a date that will burn in all of our collective memories forever more. With the airlines grounded and the nation¹s economy thrown into a tailspin, 9-11 contributed to the downturn in our local economy and, as a consequence, to our collective loss of revenues that we had counted upon for the Banks. It is no one¹s fault. But it is a fact and it is a mistake to act as if 9-11¹s impact on revenues counted upon to satisfy existing riverfront obligations and future plans did not occur. It is also an issue that offers a strong equitable argument to both the city and the county in seeking reforms to the Original Lease Agreement and Amendments thereto that each has with the Cincinnati Bengals. The Bengals, after all, approached both the city and the county, beginning in November 1993, for reformed Lease Agreements upon the premise that changes in the NFL business model and market made it economically difficult for the Bengals to remain in Cincinnati under the existing Lease arrangement and in the existing Stadium. The City first responded and renegotiated its lease with the Team in 1993 that resulted in, among other things, the city making annual ³revenue payments² to the Bengals in the Millions of Dollars. Subsequent to the December 1993 lease renegotiation the Bengals sought yet another modification in 1995 resulting in, among other things, the construction of Paul Brown Stadium and the execution of the existing may 1997 PBS Lease between the Bengals and the county and subsequent amendments thereto, some of which include the City of Cincinnati. At no time did any of those leases and the financial obligations generated within each contemplate a change in the economy; much less a change as extraordinary as that occasioned by 9-11. County taxpayers have had to respond to a spate of new obligations and expenditures for public safety as a consequence of 9-11 and have had to pick up the tab for other obligations, including those that are sales tax supported, because of the economic downturn occasioned by 9-11.

Just as this community generously responded to the ³ask² of the Cincinnati Bengals when it had no legal obligation to do so, so too it is fair, reasonable and equitable for the Team to similarly respond at this time to both the city and the county¹s ask for reformation due to the extraordinary impact of 9-11 and the global conflict that has ensued upon the local economy and revenue collections.
Advertising Earnings losses. As with several other items discussed above this involves a matter that was not envisioned nor contemplated when county taxpayers adopted the Stadium Sales Tax. The loss of this revenue stream, while not as significant as several of the items discussed above, nonetheless impacts one revenue stream helpful to the ability of city and county to construct The Banks. The original game plan that called for the construction of stadiums and garages had the stadiums next to one another on either side of the Roebling Suspension Bridge. There was no original vision that they be separated.

When the notion of separating the stadiums gained acceptance it also opened up the possibility of constructing additional parking to support the newly contemplated development in order to bring it out of the flood plain. By doing so, however, it also brought the garages within the identifiable ³Stadium Complex² area and with it all of the revenues generated from any advertising in the Garages. This is an issue that had not been contemplated by the parties at the time and results in a windfall to the team along with the loss to city, county or both and their attendant ability to construct the Banks.

Too Many Cooks Spoil the Broth
A third reason for delay involves project impediments stemming from entangling agreements that govern the development guidelines of the Banks. When Hamilton County voters adopted the Stadium Sales Tax there was no such thing as The Banks. People hoped that the construction of stadiums would lead to the construction of restaurants, night clubs, housing and the like around the stadiums. But the concept that has become The Banks was not envisioned. The attached initial renderings clearly reflect the status of thinking at the time.

Subsequent to that the city, taking on the mantle of leading development, began to push that the stadiums be separated. That led to the creation of the Riverfront advisors and ultimately the creation of both The Banks and the Port Authority.

This chronology had certain impacts that are now impediments to the Banks. The first of these was the creation of certain development guidelines that became a part of the Bengals Lease with Hamilton County that was executed in May of 1997. When that Lease and those guidelines were developed there was no such thing as an approved plan for The Banks. Accordingly, the Bengals had an interest in ensuring that quality development would arise next to Paul Brown Stadium. The intense process of the next three years that included the Bengals and the Reds via the city-county steering committee process ultimately led to the detailing of The Banks plan. That plan was then adopted as THE Urban Design Plan for Cincinnati¹s riverfront by City Council in the summer of 2000. That plan should control. It is the master Plan that both the city and the county are guided by. It makes no sense to include a third party in all of the approval processes yet the Bengals¹ unwillingness to simply allow the Banks guidelines to control has created a potential impediment in developer interest as communicated to us. If we want a streamlined process for the development of The Banks then this added layer of bureaucracy should be removed. The county should call upon the city to join with it in seeking the agreement of the Bengals to voluntarily remove this unnecessary layer of bureaucracy from what is needed to move The Banks along.

If We Aren¹t Speaking the Same Language We Cannot Communicate
A fourth reason for delay involves idea and approach conflicts between Hamilton County and the Port Authority. Clearly Hamilton County and the Port Authority reached a point of impasse in their relationship last year. Those failures of communication include the Port conveying proposed financing schemes that were untenable from the county¹s standpoint. They also included differences in approach that added cost to the county and which the county was unwilling to do because with the added cost came no increase in value ­ only expense.

In the summer of 2001 I asked for the help of the Port Authority to restructure a number of financial issues that affected the county¹s ability to advance the Banks. A copy of my July 2001 letter to the port is attached. The Port¹s response [also attached] involved a financially risky strategy that could have exposed county taxpayers to substantial financial risk. The Port¹s proposal, along with the county¹s analysis of it is also attached. As can be seen the Port¹s proposal added decades of time in paying off the debt and exposed the county to a larger risk of deficit.

Had we accepted the Port¹s proposal in 2001 Hamilton County taxpayers would today be subject to a stadium fund deficit exceeding $400 Million. County taxpayers would also be staring at a debt that would take until the year 2043 to pay off when the voters were promised in 1996 with a sales tax that would be retired within 20 years [or by 2016].

The next year the county and the Port failed to see eye to eye again. Had the Port, however, have agreed to what the county proposed we would have already begun the construction on the garages needed to complete The banks. Attached is a copy of a Resolution adopted by the County Commission in April 2002 designed to jump-start the banks. The Port refused to act upon it and with that the project was stalled. The Port had wanted to begin by developing the more costly blocks 1, 2, 5 and 6. Doing so triggered all of the parking guarantees to the Bengals and added a minimum of $4 to $6 Million of expense plus the possible necessity of having to purchase the Hilltop site in order to provide temporary replacement parking during the period of construction at millions more of expense. The inability to obtain cooperation in the form of waivers of these costs made any option other than the one selected by the county too expensive to do.

Later on during the Convergys debacle the Port abandoned The Banks plan altogether and proposed a campus style environment on The Banks to land Convergys. Until the Convergys deal was resolved the County was unable to affect any interest in the Banks.

Recently (as in late 2004 and early 2005) the county and the Port appeared to have different points of view vis a vis transportation interests and the full use of the transit Center. The difference of opinion was of some concern to the Ohio Department of Transportation. The county¹s intervention and take over of the project provided comfort to ODOT and has resulted in the county securing a firm financial commitment by ODOT to the project.

We in the County are not Without Sin
A fifth element of delay has been, unfortunately, the conduct of Hamilton County. I have been dismayed at the tired old cliché¹s used by Commission President Heimlich in the Sunday column entitled ³No Wonder the Banks is not Duck Soup² and at other times of late. In the one column referenced above we were treated to the assertion that the Banks Plan of ³restaurants, nightclubs and housing on the riverfront was promised by the county to get voters to pass a half-cent stadium sales tax.² That is just a pure fabrication. The Banks plan did not come into being until 2000 and was adopted by the city as its urban design plan for the riverfront in that year. The sales tax was passed in 1996 for stadiums ­ purportedly to keep Cincinnati a major league city with the hope that the stadiums could interest developers in the city¹s riverfront, but never that the sales tax was to pay for the riverfront.

The Sunday column was equally disingenuous in that it chose to reassert all of the tired, worn out, overused and overstated stereotypical accusations about the City of Cincinnati. Our Commission President should know better and I have urged him to act like it. His job should be to reduce conflict. Even if what he says is true it is his job to diffuse the potential for conflict and controversy. He needs to rise above the temptation to simply resort to calling the city names.

So this brings me back to the theme of this section, that being the county¹s fault and responsibility. So long as the county is in denial over its role in the lack of progress in The Banks we will never be able to work cooperatively with the city in finding the solution. The first aspect of the county¹s complicity in delay arose out of the county¹s unilateral announcement of June 10, 2006 and the selection of the county¹s preferred Master Developer, the Banks Development Company, consisting of Rob Smyjunas and his Vander Kaar Holdings, and Bill Butler and his Corporex. I was a party to that action and announcement. Notwithstanding its good intentions we have to confess that it contributed to delay and to the predicament we find ourselves in today.

The BDC was afforded an exclusive 180day time frame within which to complete the execution of a master Development Agreement. The 180-day time frame did allow a variety of other issues to be resolved, not the least of which has been to firm up state funding commitments. Nonetheless, the withdrawal of Corporex and with it the resultant failure of the BDC to materialize as the preferred developer directly led to the current delay in progress.

The second component of County contributed delay can only be attributed to the process engaged in by the County since December 6, 2005 that has resulted in the lack of sharing of information; the failure to meet with all necessary players, including primarily the Cincinnati City Council; the unilateral release of the RFQ without sharing it with the Cincinnati City Council and/or convening in session with the Council to discuss the RFQ and make certain that the city and the county agreed to its essential terms; and the failure to convene sessions of the Board of County Commissioners to discuss the status of the issue and to obtain both a clear consensus of direction and the authority to carry it out.

Closing Challenge and Opportunity
Having discussed the history of the project we now have before us the historic opportunity to commit that we will not repeat the mistakes of the past. We have a chance to pledge to the Greater Cincinnati community our commitment to collaborate in a meaningful way that ensures the best results at every step along the way. And, importantly, we have the capacity to seize the moment and the momentum and begin the project, together, through demonstrative steps that result in digging the first blade of dirt that in turn will lead to the earlier, and not the later, completion of the project.

So, what then do we do? In spite of the county¹s own failures of late there remains the inescapable conclusion that the Ordinance drafted makes it somewhat unworkable, from a practical standpoint. I understand the reasons that Ordinance came into being. I hope that some workable approach, less cumbersome, yet allowing for a full and meaningful process to occur, will take place from this point forward.

I believe that the city and the county must agree to sit down in joint session and develop a list of issues that help to guide our action. We need to work on a consensus building approach. We need to place a premium on private and outside revenues before first looking to taxpayers. We must consider the original framework that guided the visioning process in the first place. We must agree to identify the shortfall and how we will work ­together ­ to come up with the money

Hamilton County must approach the City of Cincinnati in joint session and ask initially for the city¹s help in procuring:

Reformation of the Lease Agreement between the Cincinnati Bengals and Hamilton County and/or the City of Cincinnati that will:
Remove the Bengals as a signatory on any development issues and result in the adopted Year 2000 Urban Design Plan of the Banks to be the controlling development guideline for all riverfront development;

Allow for all advertising revenue generated from parking garages built to support the Banks development to be used exclusively by the city and/or the county for Banks related costs;

Eliminate Parking revenue guarantees during the time period of Banks construction;

Modify all County-Bengals Lease obligations regarding revenues and expenses to be consistent with a ³Baltimore Style² agreement;

Require the Bengals to make a capital contribution to Paul Brown Stadium construction costs equal to the amounts promised voters and Charter Ownership Agreement purchasers

Modify the County PILOT payment obligation to Cincinnati Public Schools to be equal to the City of Cincinnati¹s $5 Million per annum for 20 years agreement;

Reconstitute the City-County Riverfront Steering Committee and schedule a discussion on the above elements as the Agenda for the initial meeting.

Commit to reserving any and all revenues generated from the items above for the specific purpose of addressing the areas of The Banks public infrastructure costs for which there is no financing secured to date.

Respectfully submitted,

___________________________
Todd Portune
Hamilton County Commissioner

Blog participants write in and Todd answers, below:

 1. Dave says:
    02 Mar 2006  at  08:18 pm | #

    Commissioner Portune,

    Thank you for the time and energy you have expended in preparing this document. This is the first time in memory any public official has been considerate enough to candidly discuss a transaction regarding the use of public funds. I hope this will set a precedent for future leaders to follow. Having read your letter the complexity of this project becomes more apparent, and the challenges clearer.

    I request your office encourage the County Auditor, Dusty Rhodes, to submit his opinion, based on current demographic and revenue trends about the financial wisdom of proceeding with this project. Nearly everybody in government is anxious to get¹er done and I understand the frustration. I make this request because Mr. Rhodes cautioned about the scenario we are currently in. He appears to have a grasp of the future implications that our children and grandchildren will inherit.

    Thank you again for your forthright letter.

    Dean,

    Are the attachments mentioned in this letter available?
 2. Tail of the Dog says:
    02 Mar 2006  at  08:41 pm | #

    Dean - I suggest you extend public invitiations to Commissioners Heimlich and DeWine to publish their own position papers on the Banks Project here.

    If they choose not to do so, please follow-up with their offices and request an explanation.
 3. Bearman says:
    02 Mar 2006  at  11:26 pm | #

    Here is the part that I never understood with this project:
    The general theory was that once the basic infrastructure was in place the opportunity should be great enough that any developer would want to make it worth its while in that this would become the most attractive land for development purposes in the Midwest if not the country. In other words, the feeling of the elected officials in 1997 and thereafter was that spending public money to build the public infrastructure of parking and streets and the like was all that should be required of taxpayers. The private development opportunities at the location of the Banks are so extraordinary that private developers should come in with their own financing for the so-called private development.

    Has there ever been a formal Request For Proposal from the city/county to developers?  Or are only hand selected developers from the county been allowed to even consider developing the land.

    It seems hard to believe that with the public infrastructure being taken care of that there is NO developer out there who can build a viable solution on the banks.  Someone help me here.
 4. Robert Wilson says:
    02 Mar 2006  at  11:55 pm | #

    I am extremely impressed that someone that busy would take the time to write such a detailed document to the public.  Awesome.
 5. Peter Deane says:
    03 Mar 2006  at  11:33 am | #

    In spite of the county¹s own failures of late there remains the inescapable conclusion that the Ordinance drafted makes it somewhat unworkable, from a practical standpoint. I understand the reasons that Ordinance came into being. I hope that some workable approach, less cumbersome, yet allowing for a full and meaningful process to occur, will take place from this point forward.

    I believe that the city and the county must agree to sit down in joint session and develop a list of issues that help to guide our action. We need to work on a consensus building approach. We need to place a premium on private and outside revenues before first looking to taxpayers. We must consider the original framework that guided the visioning process in the first place. We must agree to identify the shortfall and how we will work ­together ­ to come up with the money

    Hamilton County must approach the City of Cincinnati in joint session and ask initially for the city¹s help in procuring:

    Reformation of the Lease Agreement between the Cincinnati Bengals and Hamilton County and/or the City of Cincinnati that will:

    Remove the Bengals as a signatory on any development issues and result in the adopted Year 2000 Urban Design Plan of the Banks to be the controlling development guideline for all riverfront development;
    Allow for all advertising revenue generated from parking garages built to support the Banks development to be used exclusively by the city and/or the county for Banks related costs;

    Eliminate Parking revenue guarantees during the time period of Banks construction;

    Modify all County-Bengals Lease obligations regarding revenues and expenses to be consistent with a ³Baltimore Style² agreement;

    Require the Bengals to make a capital contribution to Paul Brown Stadium construction costs equal to the amounts promised voters and Charter Ownership Agreement purchasers

    Modify the County PILOT payment obligation to Cincinnati Public Schools to be equal to the City of Cincinnati¹s $5 Million per annum for 20 years agreement;

    Reconstitute the City-County Riverfront Steering Committee and schedule a discussion on the above elements as the Agenda for the initial meeting.

    Commit to reserving any and all revenues generated from the items above for the specific purpose of addressing the areas of The Banks public infrastructure costs for which there is no financing secured to date.

    I agree with Mr. Portune¹s list on things to do to help the Bank¹s get developed.  But there is one more thing I believe that we need to doŠ Take Phil Heimlich¹s backdoor key away from him.  All he has done with the Banks is fill the piggybank of his consulting friends. Take away the back door keyŠ If that doesn¹t happen then I hope Mallory changes the lock.
 6. Influence Peddler says:
    03 Mar 2006  at  05:58 pm | #

    Peter,

    I agree with your point in the last paragraph of your comment, however, I object to your use of cut and paste to fill space. The middle section is something we already read in order to get to your comment. You wear me out by the time I reach what you have to say. I respect your thoughts and enjoy what you say, so, all I ask is that you get to the point.
 7. Peter Deane says:
    03 Mar 2006  at  07:03 pm | #

    I agree with Mr. Portune¹s list on things to do to help the Bank¹s get developed.  But there is one more thing I believe that we need to doŠ Take Phil Heimlich¹s backdoor key away from him.  All he has done with the Banks is fill the piggybank of his consulting friends. Take away the back door keyŠ If that doesn¹t happen then I hope Mallory changes his office door lock!

    There hope that¹s better!
 8. Influence Peddler says:
    03 Mar 2006  at  07:20 pm | #

    Great...Thanks
 9. todd portune says:
    04 Mar 2006  at  12:59 pm | #

    "Bearman² wrote a question about whether a request for proposals had ever issued by the city and the county before, given the construction of the infrastructure.  It is a great question and the answer to it helps shed more light on why we at the county lost faith and confidence, not to mention trust, in the Port Authority leadership.

    As you know from review of my Statement the Port Authority was created to eliminate the influence of politics or other interests from the decision-making around the Banks and to generate greater financial interest from private sources so as to reduce the local taxpayers¹ share.  The Port Authority was the entity charged with the responsibility of selecting the developers. The Port did issue a request for qualifications from development teams.  From that list of respondents they were then to ask for proposals and select a developer.  The Port failed to complete the process and, to the extent they engaged in any kind of process, they did so in ways that caused concern.

    The Port received a number of responses from potential development teams back in 2003.  However they never narrowed the list, nor did they go on to solicit proposals for the development as everyone expected.  Instead the Port took the position that they could not advance the process any further until all of the financing contingencies were nailed down.

    That approach by the Port, however, worked to both delay the project and to probably make it more expensive from a taxpayer perspective because the Port was, in essence, telling developers that they need not come with any of their own money.  The Process telegraphed that the project would be 100% publicly funded before any proposals were necessary.  That, of course, flew in the face of the intent of city and county government.  And it flies in the face of present day reality inasmuch as we have received a proposal from a private development team that comes with over $60 Million of private financing lined up. [as a side note it is a good question why the local media has not provided more coverage about that proposal, or placed more heat on people like Commissioner Heimlich who have failed to actively pursue it]

    The Port has continued that posture, including the testimony of Jack Rouse before Council¹s Economic Development Committee on February 21st.  Rouse echoed the testimony of Corporex¹s Tom Banta that the city¹s TIF money must be made available to subsidize portions of the private side of the development.  That makes the project more expensive for taxpayers because every public dollar used in the private side is a dollar that is unavailable to complete the infrastructure, or to build the decks over Ft. Washington Way, or to build the Park.

    The Port had also caused concern to the county about the RFQ and RFP process because when it obtained the various proposals from potential developers the Port took the position that those proposals were not public documents.  The county repeatedly requested access to them and was denied.  It was not a situation that produced any trust or confidence.

    Other things came to light after we announced our preferred development arrangement with Corporex that confirmed our decision to break away from the Port was correct.  We learned that in the 24 hours between the time when the county announced the June 10 Press Conference and when the Press conference took place that representatives from the Port went to Bill Butler¹s home and tried to persuade him not to go through with the arrangement with the county saying, in essence, Œwhy put in your own moneyu [$10 Million private contribution] when we [The Port] have this lined up to be all publicly funded?¹

    That seemed to plant a seed with Butler that ultimately contributed in large measure to the arrangement breaking down between the county and Corporex as Butler got it into his mind that he had to make up for the $10 Million he was fronting the project.  Accordingly we, for example, never got past certain sticking points in the negotiations with Butler on the issue of how e get back the development rights in the event Butler didn¹t complete the project.  He insisted that the county [taxpayers] have to buy back the development rights at Market Value in the event he never built the Banks when Butler got those rights for free.  We even offered him buying them back for what he put into the project and that was not good enough - he insisted that we buy back development rights that we would have given him for free at whatever the Fair Market Value of them was at the time.  It would cost taxpayers tens of millions of dollars had we done that.

    Sorry - a bit more detail and history than you may have wanted, but I tend to think the more people know about what is really going on the better we as a community are going to be able to find the solution.  The ³mainstreampress² seems to have its own agenda here.  It seems to be promoting the notion that we can only do the Banks if the public provides a massive subsidy to the private side of the development.  Pardon the expression, but as a Lifelong Cincinnatian I think I can say it, but that is ³sooooo Cincinnati.² It consinues the insanity of the approach to stadiums and of corporate welfare.  And it reflects a real insecurity about ourselves - as if we have to beg people to do things here, which in turn, makes everything more expensive, unless, of course, you are one of the favored few in the local development commnity who seem to get every project they want with all risk eliminated by taxpayers.  And it is the favored few - just ask a gentlemen named Ken Price about whether a level playing field exists given his experience with the proposal by the Urban One Development Team that tried to get on the Port¹s radar screen.

    Thank you for the opportunity to shed more light on the project.

    Todd
10. Bob says:
    04 Mar 2006  at  05:04 pm | #

    Mr. Portune,
    It is quite refreshing to get this much context about a major development deal. Perhaps your colleagues and the Enquirer will be inspired by your open and candid dialog here at the Beacon. We need more brave officials that will talk about these issues in public forums. We¹re so used to back room dealings and you give us hope that we can have the good government we truly deserve. You¹ve gained much more respect and appreciation.

    Thanks,
11. Peter Deane says:
    04 Mar 2006  at  07:32 pm | #
    It consinues the insanity of the approach to stadiums and of corporate welfare.  And it reflects a real insecurity about ourselves - as if we have to beg people to do things here, which in turn, makes everything more expensive, unless, of course, you are one of the favored few in the local development commnity who seem to get every project they want with all risk eliminated by taxpayers.  And it is the favored few - just ask a gentlemen named Ken Price about whether a level playing field exists given his experience with the proposal by the Urban One Development Team that tried to get on the Port¹s radar screen.

    This is all about Corporate WelfareŠ every bit of itŠ It seems to me that Heimlich is playing closed door with Mallory to keep it alive.  Reminding Malloy of the endorsements that came in to save him.  The good ol boy network is alive and well in Cincinnati.

    Oh and Convergy¹sŠ yea that was garbage and also Corporate promises never returned. I don¹t believe one of them

    I hope the Dean can get an interview with Ken Price.  That way the more insider milkers will be brought outŠ get ready to set up the gallows and not a dime more for those that sit on the Port Authority!  Not a dime! They are looking for developers that will milk us more, freebees again from the tax base.  Tell them to hit the road is what I say!  These people are slugs and they use us only to pack their pockets!  Seven years of Consultants and more consutantsŠ And what should the Bengals have a say about anything about developement?  Brown has his free stadiumŠ that worm should let us go for the benifit of all people in Hamilton County.

    The more I read about these leaches the more sick to my stomach I get.

    Thank you, Mr. Portune, for keeping the public informed of the theives among us!

    Heimlich, I hope that you¹re packing your bags.  Pepper better start running running on a plateform of no more Convergy¹s deals or stinkin Stadium offers or Corporate Welfare of any kind when it involves no risk to the business in Hamilton County.  Goverment going broke for the sake of the rich is bull and we all know it! Mrs. Dumas what do you think of all this?  Where¹s Mr. Pepper!  HeimlichŠ just pack your crap we¹re done with you!
12. Peter Deane says:
    04 Mar 2006  at  08:26 pm | #

    End stalemate, get Banks built

    Enquire Dated: March 3 2006
    Editorials

    ³County Commission President Phil Heimlich needs to relinquish control of the process. He and Mayor Mark Mallory have been negotiating over how to oversee the project for the past two weeks. Both sides have agreed to the concept of a steering committee of the three commissioners and the mayor and two members of City Council. The rub is that a majority of council, led by Development Committee Chairman Chris Bortz, wants the steering committee to actually control the development process, while Heimlich, backed by fellow commissioner Pat DeWine, wants the committee to make recommendations, leaving final authority on such key issues as the choice of the developer with the commissioners. The commissioners already have sent out a request for qualifications to prospective developers over objections from the city.²

    How many people have to tell Heimlich to back off until he ³gets it²?

    P.S. And for anyone that doesn¹t know the meaning of air rightsŠ The city retains control of the ³air rights,² meaning anything that will be built above the foundation parking garages. The city also controls the use of tax increment financing funds needed to help finance the project.





Section Four: Books, Reviews, Magazines



The Essential Wallerstein, Immanuel Wallerstin, New York, 2000. This guy is a brilliant, acclaimed, kosher economist/sociologist/historian.  His study of the "world system" is exactly what I have wanted someone to explain to me.  Thrills me, reading the beginning of his book.  Quotes:

p. xviii, Introduction.  ... two basic premises of my work--the world-system as a unit of analysis, and the insistence that all social science must be simultaneously historic and systemic.
p. xix:  ...description of the historical functioning and development of the modern world-system, which I insisted was a capitalist world-evonomy.  I sought to describe its institutional pillars, its historical origin, and the rreasons why I thought it had entered into a period of systemic crisis and therefore of chaotic transition to some new order.  ... major institutional structures of this capitalist world-economy--the Kondratieff cycles**, the commodity chains, the income-pooling households, the interstate system and its hegemonic cycles, and the geo-culture....
  ....  ...five major cleavages of our modern world: race, nation, class, ethnicity, and gender.
  ...the question...: what to do.  ...Resistance, Hope, and Deception.  
I hope that you can see from this why I want to study this man's work.  It is the next step after the amazing, brilliant analysis of the rise of capitalism by Karen Armstrong in her book Islam.  (Good on the history of Islam, but a brain orgasm on her world system economic analysis!)  
  Only trouble is that this is a hard, thick book.  So I need a study chevruta*, a buddy or two with which to read it.  Local or remote, doesn't matter.  Just need that support.  Somebody?  Write me, subject line "Wallerstein".  Ellen
------------
* "Chevruta" means, I believe, a study partner (Hebrew).  In traditional talmudic study by Jews for centuries, study was never done in a solitary manner, but was always in groups of two or three, or clusters of more than one of these little partnerings.  It works.  e.

** Kondratieff cycles are long-time (200 years?) economic surges and ebbings.  Fascinating.  e.  





















The Lloyd House Salon (usually about 15 people) Meets Mondays at 5:45,
EVERY MONDAY, 52 WEEKS/YEAR come hell or high water, as my mother used to say.

We of the Lloyd House Salon gather in a spirit of
respect, sympathy and compassion for one another
in order to exchange ideas for our mutual pleasure and enlightenment.  

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
Our Salon blog is a promising interactive site:   http:lloydhouse.blogspot.com
   Interactive Yahoo Salon group, http://groups.yahoo.com/group/LloydHouseSalon
We have 45 members as of 7/05.  
For
Pot Luck  procedures including  food suggestions, mission and history visit
http://home.fuse.net/ellenbierhorst/Potluck.html .

You are invited also to visit the Lloyd House website: http://www.lloydhouse.com















> To unsubscribe from the Lloyd House Potluck Salon list, send a REPLY message
> to me and in the SUBJECT line type in "unsub potluck #". In the place of #
> type in the numeral that follows the subject line of my Weekly email. It
> will be 1,2, 3, 4, 5, or 6. This tells me which sub-list your name is on so I can  
> delete it. Thanks! ellen bierhorst